Casa Santa Restaurant

I recently ate at Casa Santa and had mixed feelings about the experience. The food was actually really good. Everything tasted fresh, the portions were solid, and the flavors were exactly what you’d hope for when going out for Mexican food. I would definitely come back just for the food alone. Unfortunately, the service at the beginning wasn’t great. Our waiter seemed to forget about us for long stretches of time until we asked what’s going on. We had to wait quite a while to order our food and to even get checked on. It felt like we were a bit overlooked compared to other tables. Overall, the food was the highlight and definitely worth trying, but the service could really use some improvement.

Always Superb Mexican food and great service. Beautiful restaurant that looks like a magazine—a feast for the eyes that elevates the experience. The enchiladas are terrific, tacos tasty, salsa and chips delicious! Great beer and drink selections. I am always happy to eat at Casa Santa. It feels more elegant than the bill would suggest.

That was our first visit after asking AI to addalar us a new place that we had never been to. Definitely had worth it. Great atmosphere, and even in the last minute, we had found a place available for reservation. Andrea was so kind and friendly while offering the best in the menu. Margaritas were delicious, and the food presentation was really good! If you are looking for a good Mexican restaurant with a nice atmosphere, just give it a try here!

I had a wonderful dining experience. From the moment we arrived, the ambiance was stunning – the restaurant’s beautiful decor created the perfect atmosphere for our meal. The food was delicious, exceeding our expectations in both quality and presentation. The fajitas were full of flavor. What truly made our visit exceptional was our server Abrahan. He was incredibly attentive throughout the entire meal, anticipating our needs without being intrusive. His kindness and warm demeanor made us feel genuinely welcomed and valued as guests. His customer service was outstanding – professional, friendly, and clearly passionate about ensuring we had a memorable experience. It’s rare to find such a perfect combination of excellent food, beautiful surroundings, and exceptional service. We left feeling thoroughly impressed and will definitely be returning. Highly recommend!

First opportunity to experience the Casa Santa and what a heavenly surprise. For starters, the chips and salsa are the bomb. With the guacamole freshly made for a truly authentic and Mexican experience. The enchiladas and chimichangas were both entrees that were on point. Yet, the star of the show was our amazing server Rio who truly took center stage. The atmosphere was amazing and the decor fabulous. This will be my new spot for a minute.

We stopped in after a show to grab a drink and some appetizers and we’re so glad we found this place! Andreah was so helpful by suggesting drinks and appetizers. Everything was delicious and when I’m back in the area I will definitely come back.

We tried to celebrate my daughter’s birthday at Casa Santa yesterday. My daughter was excited to order a dish that was flaming. So disappointed that they couldn’t get it to light. She would have ordered something else! I have NEVER been to a restaurant where they FORCED you to order a dessert in order of them to sing Happy Birthday to you. Customer service was very disappointing after dropping several hundred dollars on our meal. Ending on a positive note, the food was awesome!

I visited Casa Santa during the Devour Indy event, hoping it would be a great opportunity to try a new restaurant, but unfortunately it fell short of expectations. We ordered the pollo asado, and the chicken was extremely overcooked — so dry that it was genuinely difficult to chew. For a featured dish during a food event meant to showcase the restaurant, this was disappointing. Devour Indy is supposed to highlight a restaurant’s flavorful offerings (with smaller portions sure but flavorful) and leave diners excited to come back, but this experience did the opposite. I really wanted to enjoy the meal, but the quality just wasn’t there. I hope this was an off night, because the concept has potential, but based on this visit, it missed the mark. The other dish, cochinita pibil, was also average and ran a little dry. Just very sad for what the experience and the pricepoints of entrees are.

The food was absolutely amazing. I got the basic soft shell in our shell that goes and I loved it. They are definitely worth the price.

Casa Santa is an absolute experience! We stopped in before a show at the Fishers Event Center, and from the moment we walked in, it felt like stepping into a tropical resort. The decor is stunning and over-the-top, making it perfect for celebratory events, large parties, or just grabbing amazing photo ops. I posted pictures, and people genuinely thought I was on vacation! The service was incredibly fast, friendly, and informative, which made the experience even better. The margaritas were on the pricier side but totally worth it--strong, delicious, and well-crafted. The salsa was excellent, though the chips were pretty basic. As for food, the fried shrimp tacos were packed with flavor, and my husband got the birria tacos, which he said were delicious. If you're looking for vibes, a cool atmosphere, and great food and drinks, Casa Santa is the place to go. I can't wait to come back!

Ambiance is 10/10. So colorful, bright, fresh and exciting. I just kept looking around taking it all in. Service was quick and friendly. Very happy with the service we received. My dish (quesobirria) was delicious and I would order again. My husband said his birria burrito was good, but nothing out of this world. We will definitely be coming back and brining family. Such amazing ambiance and great service

It's a vibe, for sure! Really cute, very festive. Definitely an experience. I went for Devour and I'm glad I did. Chips and salsa come out first. I ordered the empanada for my appetizer, it was good but could've used more of the sauce that came with it. The salmon for my meal, that was cooked perfectly. The little salad that came with it was really good too. I'm not a churro person but I ordered them for my dessert and gave them to my bestie, who said they were really good. My drink of choice, House Margarita, was really good! So refreshing. Wish I would've gotten better pictures. The service was really good. The young lady who helped us told us her favorite dishes and helped us make our decision.

This spot is perfect for a fancy date night, girls night, solo hang out at the bar, birthday celebration...whatever! I love the environment! You feel like you are in a restaurant on vacation. Every booth is cozy and the decor is beautiful. I had the following: Chips, salsa and queso: chips and salsa come with the table. Queso was an add on and comes in a huge bowl! Empanadas: I ready enjoyed them. They seemed to be a mix between an empanadas and pupusa. I think because of the grain used. Pollo asada: chicken was Smokey and flavorful and it was the first mole sauce I've liked! Rice and salad were good as well Texas margaritas: loved the half sat and half Tajin rim. Made for cute photos! Churros: I love a plain churro that is crispy and sweet on the outside and fluffy and cooked through on the inside and this was it! Price was about $47 as part of the devour special so add on cost for regular dinners.

The inside of this restaurant is absolutely beautiful! Each room is a theme and very much so classic chic Tulum vibe. The service was slow. Maybe we were there during shift change but we were greeted and given chips and salsa. It was about 10 minutes before we flagged down a server that she didn't have water. The restaurant apologized but wasn't the best first impression for us! We ordered the Texas and skinny spicy margaritas. The Texas was a bit too sweet. I loved the spicy skinny margarita! We also had the house queso. This is beef, pico and cheese. This was great! Our table ordered tacos, steak burrito and arroz con polo. All were really good. The aesthetics of the table decor to the plates to restaurant decor makes this place feel very special. When the service gets its right it will be a fantastic experience!

Loved the ambiance! Felt very upscale for a Mexican restaurant (and the drink prices matched - $17 was a lot for a margarita!!!). The chips and salsa were great, we enjoyed the tableside guacamole, and our fajitas were good. Everything tasted fresh. The food prices were reasonable for the portion size. I did think the drinks were a little pricey. I appreciated that they were of high quality, but they were still a few dollars higher than drinks at similar upscale restaurants.

Casa Santa goes above and beyond with the decor! Every corner of this restaurant is beautifully decorated - 10/10 vibes and the perfect backdrop for pictures and special occasions. We came here during Devour Indy and got to choose a 3 course meal, including a margarita for only $35! And they still provided chips and salsa that was really fresh. I got the Texas margarita which uses top shelf tequila and it was the best margarita I've ever had! For appetizer I got the chicken empanada that was so flaky and flavorful. The entree I chose the salmon which was cooked perfectly, but I wish the rice was more of a Mexican style instead of being lightly flavored, and the salad was also more of a Mediterranean vibe. We ended with the churros which was perfect! The service was also great, our waiter was super friendly. The only quirk was that as soon as we were seated, they came up to us with this cart and asked if we wanted guacamole. We hadn't even gotten our water yet so it was a little confusing because we definitely didn't order guac. We thought maybe it was free so we asked the lady and she didn't speak English, so we ended up spending 10 mins trying figure out if it was free and it was not. Which makes sense, but a little misleading to make table side guac seem complimentary when it's not. But overall a good restaurant with an awesome vibe!

My husband and I visited on a Friday night without a reservation, fully expecting a wait. Fortunately, the bar seating is first-come first-served, and we were able to sit right away instead of waiting 25 minutes for a table. A nice start! The ambiance is absolutely stunning--easily Instagram-worthy. However, I did feel a bit underdressed in my simple sweater and jeans, so keep that in mind if you're planning a visit. Unfortunately, the service left a lot to be desired. While I understand it was a busy Friday night and we were seated at the bar, it took an unusually long time to get our drinks, place our order, and eventually receive our food. The entire experience took two hours, and we noticed that people who sat at the bar after us were being served their food and drinks before we were. When the food finally arrived, the portions were generous, but the flavors were underwhelming. I ordered the arroz con pollo, and my husband got the fajitas. The fajitas were definitely the better choice. I also paid $2 extra for grilled veggies, which I'm not sure I got... There were a few large chunks of cooked tomato, but not quite what I expected. Despite the slow service and average food, we'll likely give this place another chance, as we understand it might have been an off night and not the best circumstances for a great experience. That said, I'd be hesitant to recommend it just yet, especially if you're looking for a quick or standout meal.

I have been wanting to try Casa Santa since I saw it was going to open. I finally came with my family and it's such a pretty place. The decorations are so nice, the staff were so friendly, and the food was amazing. We ordered empanadas to share and I really liked them. The dough was crunchy and the inside was filled with chicken, mushroom & cheese, and pork (I believe). The arroz con pollo was also delicious. The serving sizes were really large and I had a lot of food left over. I would definitely come again and try other plates.

The atmosphere is wonderful classy is great for a date night or evening with the family. Plenty of seating throughout a full bar wonderful appetizers to choose from the food was absolutely mouthwatering and delicious, and our server was absolutely amazing on her recommendations and made our first time here an absolute dream. I would highly recommend anyone in the mood for authentic Mexican cuisine to visit.

Excellent food, service and ambiance. I was so surprised by this place. Our waiter, Alphonso, took excellent care of us. The food is very authentic and the portions are large. Prices are a little higher than other local places but the food is worth it.

Casa Santa is fantastic!! When you walk in you immediately feel like you're being transported from Indy to a vibrant restaurant in Mexico. Each room is unique in design and flows perfectly together, creating an awesome decor. The food was fresh and delicious! We had the table side guacamole and tuna tostadas for appetizers. Then we all ordered the Molcajete. This entree was AMAZING! Not only was the bottom lit on fire which was a great extra touch, but the chicken, steak, chorizo, shrimp, and the cheese were outstanding! The whole group was thrilled and we had to take all leftovers home. Finally we ended with the churros topped with caramel and cinnamon sugar which was the perfect ending to an epic meal. I would HIGHLY recommend trying Casa Santa. The food was delightful, the service was very attentive, and the atmosphere was lively. I can't wait to come back!

This place is gorgeous - the vibe in the restaurant is amazing, decorated to perfection. The bar space is really long if just wanting to grab a drink - I could picture just hanging out with friends for a few drinks and chips/salsa. We had to wait to get a host/hostess to seat us, but really the food came quick and the orders prepared as specified. Food was good, portion size big so you feel like you are getting a lot for your money. The mango margarita was delicious - definitely recommend trying. I didn't see Sangria on the menu, but that would be a good addition if they don't have it! Stop by and check this place out whether in a large or small group as it's sure to please!

I'm really disappointed to be writing this review because I've had great experiences here in the past. I've visited about 5 to 7 times and always loved it, so I would've easily given it five stars before. I recommended the restaurant to my family, and a group of about 10 of us gathered for dinner. Unfortunately, the experience was far from what I expected. The music was overwhelmingly loud--so much so that it felt like I was in a Zumba class. Several people around us were also complaining, and we repeatedly asked if they could turn it down, but nothing changed. I'm going through a divorce, and I was really looking forward to having a quiet conversation with my family, but the noise made that impossible. I was so frustrated that I ended up paying for my drink and leaving. I did mention the situation to the hostess, and she explained that the owner likes the music loud. It seems like the sound system might be concentrated in the elevated area, which could explain why the noise level was unbearable for those of us seated elsewhere. I really wish they would have offered to move us to a different section. It's a shame because I've always enjoyed this place, but I won't be returning anytime soon if this is the atmosphere they're going for.

The food was amazing--there were a lot of different flavors. Omg, our drinks were amazing. Our service was great. Our server was very respectful and understanding. He took good care of us. I will be back to try the rest of the menu. The environment was very beautiful--there were a lot of different things to look at. The entire set-up and style are beautiful--they remind me of the islands!

My husband took me here for my bday. It was wonderful. We had the Devour menu. We also had a house margarita and a Texas margarita, both great. The service was even better than the food and that says a lot!!!

We decided to try this place out last night. We were seated promptly and they quickly brought chips and salsa. We ordered a few cocktails and a couple sodas. For appetizer we got the queso with beef. This was pretty good. We enjoyed the fact it was thicker than most other places. We ordered steak and chicken fajitas. I had to use google translate to find out if they used chicken breast for their fajitas or not. They do in fact use chicken breast. The steak had a great flavor but be prepared to chew because it's tougher than shoe leather. The chicken on the other hand was delicious. The beans and rice were also tasty. For dessert I can't remember the name of it but it was like dessert tacos with fruit and that was also delicious. The ice cream that came with it was not so good. I don't know what the tacos were made of but they were impossible to cut so we had to pick it up and eat it which usually isn't a problem for me but when it's covered in chocolate and caramel that was messy. I loved the decor and the place looked really nice inside, much more toned down than the typical Latin restaurants. Here is where they lost us. The music was louder than what you would find in a dance club and that also happens to be the style of music they played. The table next to us was loud, drunk and obnoxious which would have been fine if I were in a club and not in a pricey upscale Latin restaurant. Service was painfully slow. The menu is extensive and they should have something for everyone. They had some exotic dishes that I don't think we would like such as grasshoppers, octopus etc. I would go back and try them at lunch but if we walk in the door to dance mix 2000 then we will turn around and leave.

Good food, good drinks, and such a fun and cute ambiance! Loved the decor of this restaurant, it felt like I was on vacation being there with all of my friends! I had the arroz con pollo which was yummy as expected--I wish they had pickled jalapeños but that's about the only thing I'd change. I'm sure I'll be back! Xoxo, Is this thing on?

I thought this place was gonna be your typical white person mexican restaurant like El Rodeo and La Hacienda, however I was wrong. It has a great ambiance, interesting food options, and a good bar. It's rather big, with the bar right up front. Margaritas were good, food was excellent! Service was friendly. Definitely recommend.

Food is outstanding. We've been here 3 times now and each time has been fantastic. Their birria is delicious, the meat skewers my husband had were fantastic and my chimichanga was delicious. We can't wait to return!

Yes!! Finally a decent upscale Mexican restaurant! It seems like every Mexican place has the same boring menu and the same terrible margaritas. But Casa Santa has amazing cocktails, and not just tequila cocktails -- these drinks would easily rival pricier cocktails at any upscale bar downtown. And the food is so much better than all the typical Mexican places. I'm so happy to have found this place, and I can't wait to go back!

Came here before a concert at Forever Deer Creek, the location is very convenient before a show. It was decorated really cool, each space was a little different. Our server was great fast to order and bring food. The food was excellent I loved the Quesobirria. Can't wait to come back!

Friends told us to go and I'm glad we did! Great time dining there and looking forward to going back. The margaritas were great, a little too expensive though $17 for Casa Verde. Chips and salsa were good. The salsa had a good smokey taste and the chips were warm. The quesabirrias tacos were delicious! As was the arroz con pollo. Great warm fresh tortillas. The interior was wonderful. Nice and modern looks. They could choose better music. Hard rock was not the right vibe. We are definitely going back with more friends. There looked like some great larger tables to reserve for larger groups.

Food? Atmosphere Staff Margaritas This is our new favorite Mexican-inspired restaurant. If you add apps and drinks to your meal, you'll rack up $125+ pretty quickly! Our favorite server is Sindi and we'll be back there next weekend.

Clean, good atmosphere, plenty of seating, interesting decor and layout, great service and delicious food. We will be back. And just an FYI we saw it was full on open table but went anyway and got right in.

Very cool vibe and ambiance. Love the decor and visual experience. However, the food was unfortunately very average. We ordered the house dip which was pretty decent. We split the fajita and chicken quesadilla. The fajita veggies were definitely undercooked and still somewhat raw. The chicken was nicely spiced. The quesadilla was very bland. Just two entrees and a dip was a bit overpriced for the quality. I wish the food was better because it seems like a fun spot but I don't feel as though I will likely be returning.

Guys oh my god, such great food, beautiful ambience, service was great. I got the mentiras con cariño to drink, so good and presented beautifully. Worth the steep cocktail price, in my opinion. Tableside guacamole was stunning and delicious. Salsa was okay, I personally like mine more chunky, but the flavor was great. The queasabirria tacos were so good I finished them all and was stuffed, but I just couldn't put them down. Our server, Jackie, was sweet and incredibly attentive. Again the ambience and the music was fun and I'd absolutely come back!

Casa Santa did not disappoint. As you first walk in the first thing you notice is the decor and well thought out floor plan. The restaurant is very spacious , and gives you all the vibes you'd want for a nice dinner with friends or a date. The service was excellent. We were immediately greeted with smiles and great energy. It was our first time there so we really relied on our server to inform us about the menu, and he did just that. He told us what appetizers went well with our drinks and what was popular. The drink I ordered was the Idolo and I was a fan of it because I love anything with hibiscus. It wasn't too strong and tasted great. For an appetizer we ordered the Calamari Frito, and I was instantly impressed. The avocado dipping sauce with it was such a great compliment to the dish. My main course was the Alambres. The plating and look of the dish was gorgeous as it was 3 skewers hanging from a plate. The aesthetic also matched the taste, all the meat was well seasoned and the flavors all added to a great experience. I will definitely be back!

The food was excellent and the dining experience was fantastic! Overall I will definitely be back. Highly recommend this place!

This place is absolutely incredible. The whole vibe when you walk in is super glamorous with the fountain and decorations. The pozole was fine, definitely under seasoned. The chimichanga and beans were great. The rice was DRY, but not bad when mixed with the beans. Only giving 4 stars because the server wasn't super nice or friendly to us. Will definitely be back

First things first the food was most outstanding and portions were massive. Be prepared to come very hungry or if not share a meal such as the burritos or the tacos and still be stuffed . Service was excellent. Host was friendly as well as the waitress both were helpful. Very upscale modern Mexican and tropical vibe . Very unique and colorful light fixtures as well as very comfortable seats . To top it off for dessert the Tres Leches cake was sooooo good . Moist served with berries and chocolate sauce . Overall highly recommend Casa santa . 5 stars on every aspect!!!

Excellent food and cocktails. Gorgeous upscale ambiance. Wonderful service. Highly recommend.

Experience was very pleasant. Only critique is that the food took a bit longer than expected. We were told 8 mins and it was more like 15 mins. The food quality was excellent. I had a skinny marg that was very good as well. The atmosphere was very cool. Lots of greenery and upper quality booths/table. Every table had fresh flowers. The hostess said everything is imported from Mexico. Would recommend.

Casa Santa, what a pleasant surprise. Fantastic food and wonderful service. I had a tuna tostada (appetizer as my entree), so good. It was prepared perfectly rare (raw), with avocado-pineapple relish. Wow, just wow! Hubs enjoyed a combo platter with taco, tamal, and sope. He was very happy. He noted that the sope was the best thing on the plate. With a beer and a Diet Pepsi we were under $45, before tip. That said, they had some stunning plates coming out of the kitchen. There is a tomahawk steak that has a fire presentation. Phenomenal. The ambience is just lovely. Quite authentic it in no way cheesy or camp. Loved everything about Casa Santa. Will be back...soon.

This was easily one of the best restaurant experiences that I have had in years. The food was fast and amazing. Service was outstanding, and I had a good conversation with the GM. Ambiance was great....but obviously it was the food. Even had tableside fresh-made guac. We will 100% go back

Al'Faso was our server, wonderful and very attentive. Food was outstanding!!! This was our second time here and tried three different entrées and all of them were fabulous. Highly recommend coming and trying it out.

We were a party of 12 with reservations, we had one waitress. Waited 4 hours to get our food on a Thursday evening. They don't have enough staff to handle groups this size. The food was alright, when it did come out it was not even hot. Service was poor, I don't see myself coming back.

Nice place for lunch or dinner. This was our first time there so we played it safe with chicken Quesadillas and Beef Fajitas. They were delicious and the house queso dip was wonderful! We had plenty to take home and my husband saw a dish come out that made him want to come back to try!! It is called Alambres, I attached a photo of it below. Our server Dayana was wonderful & checked our table often. We loved the decor of the different area, really nice! We can't wait to go back!!

The food was very tasty since moving from California it's been hard to find a place where I actually really enjoy the food . 10/10 the service was amazing very engaged and very nice ! Me and my husband and kids enjoyed the atmosphere the whole restaurant is just so beautiful definitely coming again !

TERRIBLE SERVICE !!! IF I COULD GIVE 0 STARS I WOULD!!!! Had a reservation and have been waiting for almost 30 minutes!!! Spoke to manager and he said he couldn't do anything about it, very rude man!! My daughter and I share a birthday and wanted to try this place out, so disappointed. Staff is so rude as well!! Don't come here unless you are willing to wait FOREVER

I made reservations for a party of 12 for my birthday with my family & friends. Reservations was for 7pm. We waited 2 hours for our food to come out. The waiter NEVER gave us refills on our drinks. We even asked for silverware more than twice like how else are we supposed to eat? They kept telling us they had a party of 30 that they were dealing with first. They were more prioritized on the other party. Don't make reservations if you can't handle that many people..! Our bill was over $700 and was charged $132.00 !!!! for TIP?!! AND was charged for cucumbers??? They sang happy birthday for the other party but I didn't receive that either!! We weren't well taken care of. We waited another hour for our check. The waiter was never to be found. Horrible experience.The food had no flavor and our food was cold!! Really disappointed we spent all that money for poor service. Overall, it's a beautiful place for a cocktail but I don't recommend going for a celebration.

Love the atmosphere, we had great service and the food felt like it was authentic. The margarita was very good. Arracheras were a little dry but everything else that my table got was good

I love Casa Santa!! First time coming here and it was amazing! The restaurant was beautiful. We made a reservation at 7PM on a Friday which I'm glad we did. The place was packed! And I can see why. Their drinks were delicious. I had the margarita of the day which was pomegranate. Definitely my favorite. Their food was out of this world. I had the steak tacos with rice and beans. Cooked to perfection! I can't wait to come back again. 10/10 recommend

The ambiance of Casa Santa can't be beat! Each section is a different vibe, it's like stepping into another world! We definitely got taken to flavortown! The salsa had the perfect kick and I got the steak fajitas! Downsides were the wait for food and the price! A little pricey for drinks and I felt like I was skimped on steak in my fajitas. Definitely way more veggies unfortunately.

I've been to Casa Santa twice now, once the week they opened and loved it so much I went the next week with more family. The vibes of this place are really fun and the interior is really beautiful! Felt like I was back at a resort! The food was great but my favorite was the carnitas tacos. The food is a bit more authentic and higher end than your run of the mill Mexican places so their prices do reflect that. I loved their tomatillo salsa! The margarita was really good and strong. It could be pricy if you bring all your kids but I would definitely do a girls night or couples night! We had great service both times. Will be back again!

The atmosphere is awesome! The food and service are also amazing! Food is much more authentic than your usual Mexican restaurant. Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. Have been waiting for a great upscale Mexican restaurant!

I can't say enough good things about this restaurant. The food, service and ambiance are all amazing. Prices are a little higher than your traditional Mexican locally but well worth it and certainly not outrageous. Noblesville is very fortunate to have Casa Santa. This is one of the best new restaurants in Indy. It gives the feeling of a combination between South Beach and Cabo. Try it, you'll love it.

Arrived 5 min early for our reservation for husband's birthday. Waited quite a while for hostess to appear. Told her my name and that we had a reservation, but instead of checking us in she just wrote down the number in our party (2) on a sheet of paper. Waiter said they didn't have any soft drinks except sweet tea at the moment. Borderline "hard sell" for alcohol and appetizers. Throughout the meal our waiter adressed me as "Honey". Husband said his meal was "ok". The meat in my carnitas street tacos was bone dry and hard as a rock. Managed to eat one. The rest were inedible. After we left, Open Table messaged us and asked why we were No Shows. Hostess had never checked us in, and thus never saw our reservation - which also explains why there was no birthday song for my husband.