Rainer H.
Yelp
The best compliment I can give to Cathy's is it's basically a big room that's not Club Cafe or House of Blues. Oh, and the staff is quite nice too. But wow, what a totally missed opportunity for a good gay bar in Boston. Everyone knows that Boston has had a pretty pathetic gay scene for years now, and this just is another mediocre place to add to the list of places to unenthusiastically go to on a Saturday night. It's unfortunately that the owners landed an incredible space with so much potential but basically squandered it.
This place has zero character. Basically it has a pool table, a dart board, some TVs and a patio that closes early. The space is oversized for the number of people that go here. Even on nice nights, the patio is surprisingly underutilized most of the time. Perhaps because there's no bar out there. The music...ugh, don't get me started on the music selection. At least the drinks and staff are fine. Beer is beer, and they pour it properly. Seating is plentiful. And if you're in a tight circle with the flag football or softball teams then you'll have fun going here with a bunch of your friends.
But Jesus H. Christ you have all this space. Do something with it. Wednesday Trivia night is a start, and that's fun. But how about some other stuff for all the other days of the week. A beer garden during the day outside. A tea dance. Move all the tables to the side and have a line dancing night. Or sexy twister. Drag bingo. 80s night. It can be all of those things or none of those things, but whatever it may be, just do something and see what sticks.
Instead, the owners are like Maria von Trapp spinning around in a meadow on a mountaintop singing "Look at all the f's I give." It's like they don't even care. Or perhaps they know they don't have to try hard since expectations are so low in this city anyway. (There is also the unconfirmed rumor that they have a short term lease and are investing as little as possible since the place will be turned into condos in a few years like all the other property surrounding it. I mean, a two story building and a huge parking lot in the middle of the South End? You know that's a year or two from going the way of condos just like Ink Block and the other properties right up the street.)
The ironic thing is there's a huge pent up demand in Boston for a good gay bar. Go down to Ptown on a summer weekend and half the people in the bars are from Boston. Those people would love to have a solid place to go in Boston for the other 9 months of the year. Sadly, Cathy's doesn't fill that void. (Any smart investors out there want to launch a gay bar?)
BTW this review is for the bar only. I'm not reviewing the food because I don't see a negative star option.