Snooseman P.
Yelp
First off, Charcoal Inn North is the same as Charcoal Inn. Someone just forgot to add the "North". The address on Geele tells the tale. Charcoal Inn South (South 8th St.) is in the same family but are two separate businesses. Some folks say the food and menu is the same, others have a definite preference. The website gives you all the details. Now for the rating. Here's the bottom line. The only places in Sheboygan were you get a bad hamburger are the fast food joints. Almost every place else, restaurants, bars, Fireman's Picnics you name it use a Sheboygan Hard Roll, generally grilled on real charcoal (1st choice) but not always, sometimes a gas fired Chargrill (2nd choice) and sometimes just a griddle (3rd & last choice) but still good. Sheboygan made bratwurst (Not Johnsonville or Hillshire Farms) locally made (like Sheboygan Sausage Co.) and seasoned primarily with salt & pepper and never pre-cooked like you get at Miller Park in Milwaukee. Those things shouldn't even be call bratwurst. Call 'em "Ball Park Wurst" or something similar, but not bratwurst. I did part of my growing up in the Sheboygan area and on Saturday nights we'd go to the drive-in theater in Sheboygan and always stop at Schultz's on Calumet Dr. Which is still there by the way, just not the original building. Sadly, Charcoal Inn South & North have surpassed them, at least for my preference but I still go there on occasion, usually when Charcoal Inn North & South are closed. One has to remember that restaurant choices are personal opinions and of course not everyone will agree. Check the website and check the menu prices. No $8 or $9 hamburgers here. You get a lotta bang for your buck and taste beyond compare