Cheese Lovers
Pizza restaurant · East Harlem ·

Cheese Lovers

Pizza restaurant · East Harlem ·

Pizzeria with delicious homemade bread, great pizza, and friendly service

friendly service
cheese pizza
great pizza
inconsistent hours
high prices
pepperoni slices
white slices
homemade brownies
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null
Cheese Lovers by null

Information

2166 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10035, USA Get directions

$1–10

Order delivery
See Menu
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Vegetarian options
Comfort food

Information

Static Map

2166 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10035, USA Get directions

+1 212 722 7252
cheeseloversmenu.com

$1–10 · Menu

Features

•Popular for lunch
•Popular for dinner
•Good for solo dining
•Vegetarian options
•Comfort food
•Credit card accepted
•Debit card accepted
•Contactless accepted

Last updated

Jan 13, 2026

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2026 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,992 Cities

Where to Eat in East Harlem | Eater NY

"Walking on Third Avenue I went into Cheese Lovers Restaurant, which turned out to be a pizzeria that lives up to its name — the pizzaiola smiled that 'everything has cheese in it' — and served a decent margherita slice ($5) alongside odd garlic knots shaped like napkin rings." - Robert Sietsema

https://ny.eater.com/2023/8/18/23829703/east-harlem-restaurants-burgers-fish-bakeries
Cheese Lovers

William B.

Google
I love this place. Not a chain but a small friendly place. I'm always greeted with a smile and a " how are you my friend". The personal size cheese pizza is great lots of cheese fresh from the oven . Mmmm And you can shop the thrift store in the back while waiting for your pizza to bake . And try the home made brownies!

Anne Hathaway did not spit in my F.

Google
I'd actually wanted something like a chopped cheese upon approach, but there were so many pizza slices on display that I felt compelled to get pizza again. I liked the pepperoni & white slices. They embody what Harlem pizza should be! Great friendly service too!

wen W.

Google
Very friendly service and food is great.

coreen

Google
Their phone number is not working… I accustomed eating with them all the time…

Fatimat S

Google
Hours consistently inconsistent with Google. Cheese lovers is a great pizza spot however they’ve missed their mark with their operating hours. Many times I’ve tried visiting the location in the evening only to find it closed, the most recent being a Saturday at 7pm. You would think that’s prime time for a pizza joint. Even if you’re closing early, just update your Google hours so you won’t have hungry and disappointed customers.

Tracey W.

Google
Had to put a good review for this pizza place been dealing the them before change there the staff there is pleasant. I had a issue with my order they they gave me credit for the order. Thank you so much. Cheese Lover and the staff.

Madison F.

Google
This place has good cheese pizza but they close on random days. How do you close hrs before your google closing time? Can't be open on Tuesday nights and closed on Saturday nights.

kittywarrior 1.

Google
Very friendly and clean....great food...very satisfied.. especially there personal pizza ..
google avatar

Carol M.

Yelp
I ordered chicken fettuccine Alfredo through seamless along with garlic knots. The knots were dry and they didn't taste good at all. There was a seasoning on top that dried it out even more and I ended up throwing it away. The pasta was not any better. The Alfredo sauce was very runny (think water) and didn't have any taste of what an Alfredo sauce should taste like. The chicken was salty, thin pieces of grilled chicken. And the pasta was like 3 different types of noodles where some of them were actually fettuccine. The best part of my meal was the seltzer water. Grand total of almost $18 (not including my tip). I wouldn't trust Cheese Lovers with anymore pasta tbh.
google avatar

Marc B.

Yelp
This definitely wasn't the kind of "chicken" I was expecting to get with my pasta. The vodka sauce was ok, not that big of a fan. This dish cost be about $13

Searius R.

Yelp
Prices for a slice is too high. $3.50? It's not that good, stay away. And it isn't open everyday, shady