TJ B.
Yelp
There's a lot love about this place. First, let's talk about the BEER, food feedback at the end; There are a lot of breweries. They're not all good... then there is RAR. They made a name for themselves in the very out of the way town of Cambridge, MD and people would STILL travel hours and line up for another hour to buy the beer. It's that good. The beer is excellent. All of it. Some of the best around.
Some reviews here have talked about cost, so let me put that into perspective; They have $5 pints every day! ...along with $6 and $7 options. You can sit in Annapolis and drink their very flavorful Lite offering for 5 bucks. That's not bad. The beers many come here for would be the New Englands and Fruited Sours and those are $9 pours. While it is more than I like to spend on a beer, from the source, at least it is a 16 oz pour!! You do not have to search far to find breweries giving you sad little 10-12 oz. pours for the same price. So have a couple of the high ABV pints, enjoy them, and jump to the $5/$6 options which is what you should be drinking anyway after those 9% hazys.
They have flights for $10! Four different Four oz. RAR pours for 10 bucks. That is pretty good. You can sample beers that people are lining up next to you to buy in $9 to-go cans, but you get to try several different varieties fresh from the draft. And finally, in addition to a huge selection and variety of their own beer, they have a constantly rotating selection of guest taps. Usually 2 beers each from 4 different brewers. It's a different list every time I go in.
They also have a full liquor menu of craft cocktails I'd like to try. I have seen many of them served, made with extreme care, and guests seem happy.
With all that, it is not a surprise that this place has been packed every weekend and most weeknight evenings. It's a mixed blessing, of course. You want them to do well, but you would like to get a seat. They do have a large outdoor heated deck that is just going to keep getting better as the weather warms up.
The staff is great- Management, bartenders, and servers. Very friendly and enthusiastic. If they had any opening month bumps they are constantly correcting and hiring new staff to fill in. I'm sure the popularity, while appreciated, exceeded their expectations and they would have doubled the size of this place had they known. That said, it's really beautiful inside with long community tables that make you feel like you are in a proper social beer garden. Get to know your neighbors. Enjoy it.
The FOOD is all excellent but served in comically small portions. There is no getting around that. You look at the menu, you read the descriptions, your sandwich comes and you did not know they even made rolls that small. It is unfortunate, but just know that ahead of time. You are getting child sized meals but at adult quality. Look at this as a place to drink great beer with friends. The food should be something to munch on while enjoying a draft. If you come with a group as a dinner spot you may be disappointed. If cost is not an option for you, then just order extra food/sides and you'll be fine. I look at this as a place to drink that has snacks, rather than a place for food that has beer.
I tried the Chessie Burger which is an excellent smash burgher. Nothing not to like but the size. Same with the Cheesesteak. I was shocked by the tiny bun, but it was stuffed full of rib eye with a unique beer cheese sauce. The loaded tots vary... sometimes they can use a little more "loading", but all good.
The Fish and Chips are a unique offering to this location and were very good, if not small. The couple next to me got the lobster rolls which are listed as market price and cost $35 each. They were plump chock full of lobster, but they were turned off by the amount of food they got for the price. Buffalo wings look great. They are sold by weight so you'll get a pound of wings which seems on par, from a portion standpoint, with other pubs. My friend got the veggie burger and said it was probably the best veggie burger he's ever had.
Only other nit is the servers will ask you if you want chips or side of sauce (when I asked for hot sauce for my cheesesteak) but all that is an added cost. It's not a lot, but just ask "how much" anytime someone offers to bring you something. It's okay, I know that's effort on their part I just wanted to know up front. So, by the time I added a small side of potato chips and hot sauce, my mini cheese steak was $16. I've had $16 cheese steaks that were the size of my arm. This isn't that.
So, even with a couple nits up top, yes, this place is still 5 stars.
How could it not be?
They have no reason to increase the portion size of the food when you can't get a seat on the weekend as it is. :)
Come for the beer! Everything else is just gravy on your experience. Such a well planned out establishment. Enjoy. Bring friends. Buy some 4 packs to-go.