Mike L.
Yelp
Given their name, you could understand my confusion after seeing Chocolate Fish show up in my Yelp results for local coffee shops. It's not to say it's weird for a chocolate shop to serve coffee, but for a hot second there, I thought I had typed in my search incorrectly in my drowsy state of mind. Of course, that's before I realized that this place isn't actually a chocolate shop at all. Which then led to me looking up how they got such a seemingly random name (a chocolate fish is a chocolate confection in New Zealand that is rewarded for a job well done). Which, naturally, piqued my curiosity as to how good this place just might be. I've got to say - I didn't figure that falling down a rabbit hole would end up dictating where I'd end up getting coffee to start my day!
Now, almost immediately after stepping inside, I felt pretty optimistic about my chances here. While there isn't a ton of seating relative to its size, the look of this place is great - the decor is modern, the vibe is cozy, and there is coffee roasting set-up sits in the open for everyone to see. As for the menu, it's pretty straight forward, with its half dozen or so varieties of espresso, handful of coffees and cold brews, "down under' options, and teas. They also have a smattering of sourdough toast offerings and some baked goodies in their display case, but be aware it's all generally lighter coffee shop fare, in case you're looking for something more substantial to eat.
-- SMASHED AVO TOAST - Avocado, EVOO, Lemon, Salt & Pepper on Sourdough Bread with an Egg (+$2)
As decent as it looked, this was pretty underwhelming. The eggs were nicely cooked and there was a decent amount of avocado, but there was a smidge too much salt and it was barely toasted, if at all - super pale in color and lacking that toasted texture.
-- NITRO COFFEE - Nitrogenated Japanese-style Flashed Brewed Iced Coffee
Not amazing, but not bad either. The coffee had a smooth consistency and it didn't taste all that bitter. Most importantly, it had a nice caffeine kick to it, as it definitely perked me up a bit.
-- LAVENDER FIELDS LATTE - Ghiradelli White Mocha with Lavender
I didn't try much of this one, but what I did have was just okay. To me, it felt more like a regular white mocha/latte, as the lavender felt very subtle. Still, it was pretty refreshing on such a hot day.
-- MINT MATCHA - Matcha Latte Sweetened with Mint
The description of this sounded both interesting and odd while the taste of it landed somewhere in the middle. The blend of the mint and matcha was a little funky in the beginning, but it was fine a few sips in. Still, I'd prefer a plain matcha instead.
While the coffees and toast were a bit of a mixed bag, service here is pretty solid. All of the workers who helped us were quite nice and fairly efficient in preparing our orders. Despite how great it was, though, I can't say it's enough for me to round up from THREE AND A HALF STARS. None of it is to say that Chocolate Fish is bad, especially since the most "traditional" drink I've tried is by far the best. It's just that while others have clearly had great experiences here, and despite how this place is definitely worth trying, I personally might be more inclined to head to the likes of Temple instead.