Jennifer W.
Yelp
On Friday 10/10/2014, my husband and I had dinner at Cibreo. The reviews on Yelp were so great, but the overall experience, and the food, fell incredibly short.
The "human menu" is awkward. One of the staff seats themselves at your table, and reads a list of menu items available for you to order.
The restaurant is old, outdated, and there were flies on the wall, buzzing around our wine glasses, and on the tablecloth of the empty table next to us.
After you order your food from the "human menu," they bring an assortment of foods- "a present from the chef". Would have been a nice touch, if the food had been delicious. They bring out tripe (my husband tried it, and did not like it...full disclosure, I did not try it), a garlicky ricotta terrine-like spread (good flavor, bad texture) , chicken liver crostini (bite size), mushrooms (rubbery), and another terrine-like spread that tasted like a caprese salad in the form of a shmear. All in all, the textures paired poorly together. The flies continued to buzz around us.
Delicious: we shared the polenta with white truffle. It was great. See pic. However, they do charge double for the white truffles. This is typical at most restaurants during truffle season. I had the minestrone soup with white tuna. It was pretty good.
With dinner, they bring you a bread bone- see pic. I don't get this.
I ordered the chicken and ricotta meatballs (2 good-sized balls), which were delicious. Sadly, they came with whipped potatoes, that had a pudding-like skin on top. I think they may have been microwaved before being served to me. My husband had the rabbit, which had many bits and pieces of cartilage, making it inedible. The rabbit came with soggy, room-temperature green beans.
We skipped dessert, and decided to get gelato down the street. The owner asked how our meal was, and we told him not so great. He shrugged, and walked away. He did not care to learn what we were disappointed in. They brought us a cheesecake with an orange-gelee on top. It was not good. I advised our hotel concierge (Helvetia Bristol) of our experience.