El A.
Yelp
I called Cindy's on a Sunday afternoon for an impromptu 4-person mani/pedi party, and they told us to come right in. They gave us their private group space in the basement, so we could make noise and talk about whatever we wanted. The four technicians who assisted us were efficient and careful - all of us were happy!
That was almost two years ago, and I've been a regular Cindy's client ever since. I don't live in the neighborhood, but it's worth my time to stop off in the UWS a couple of times a month to get my nails done well. Plus, there's a Le Pain Quotidien across the street, and The Blue Donkey Bar next door is great for happy hour and Jets games.
Don't get me wrong, there are a few novices in the batch, but most of the ladies here are seasoned pros. I've gotten regular and gel manicures and pedicures, and highly recommend the gel pedicures as they last up to a month. The massages are pretty good, too. I especially recommend Amy, Helen and Sally.
The decor is okay; the music is abysmal. Still, it's an inviting space, and they've renovated with new, awesome pedicure chairs in the last few months. Technicians provide a black basket for your shoes and accessories and carry your belongings while you get situated, which is a nice touch of courtesy. The owner doesn't let technicians gossip with one another - I think that's both a gift and curse for a trip to the nail shop, but the ladies are very focused on their work, and their high standards are evident.