Bob F.
Yelp
Our first visit to Cinq-Mars was a year ago on the recommendation of our next door neighbor here in LA. Went for lunch with our favorite French couple and we had a wonderful meal. Such a comfortable room -- not huge at all and just warm and friendly. Lunch was not fussy -- just nicely prepared dishes with great herbs and clean, flavorful recipes. One of the better meals we had in Paris.
This year, during a ten week stay in Paris, we managed to get back to Cinq-Mars twice with slightly different results. Took a visiting friend with us for dinner and had a truly exceptional meal -- great seared tuna, awesome lamb stew, marvelous asperges blanches et vertes, a simple mesclun greens salade that was mind-blowingly good -- just wonderful food all served by a lovely, charming young woman who made such a great connection with us.
Three nights later, on our last night of the ten-weeks stay, we returned for one more meal before heading back to LA. Being creatures of habit, we did a re-run of the hits from the previous visit -- and while the starters were every bit as good as three nights before, the plats were off. The lamb stew gravy was noticeably sharper and more acidic, not as rich and deep. The tuna was nowhere near as fresh/clean tasting. Not bad, mind you. Just not as good as the previous visit, as if a different kitchen crew was in charge on the two nights.
Enough of a difference to change our impression of Cinq-Mars? Nope! It's a great place and they definitely know what they're doing. But it does show that even the best of places can vary from night to night.
Our recommendation: a fine, highly enjoyable, comfortable, reliably good non-touristy place. Don't hesitate to go.