Bailey B.
Yelp
For me, City Cafe is serviceable but not impressive. It was extremely busy around lunch time on a Tuesday, with only one table left for us to settle.
Our waitress was very pleasant but could NOT get our drink orders right. Two of us asked for Pepsi. One was brought Pepsi, but the other (who happens to get migraines from fake sugar) was brought Diet Pepsi THREE times in a row. She gave up and ordered sweet tea after that. The first, who originally got a regular Pepsi, was given a Diet for a refill. Not sure if they got their tanks switched or what, but it was frustrating.
Our orders were as follows:
Chicken fried steak, slaw, mashed potatoes;
Country fried steak, mashed potatoes, and dry lima beans;
And a fried chicken breast fillet with mac and cheese and dry lima beans.
The chicken fried steak was probably the best of the meats. The country fried steak was adequate. For some reason, I misunderstood and expected my fried chicken to be an actual fried chicken breast rather than a fillet, which was closer to chicken schnitzel (thin cutlet, no bone, crispy breading). My mistake, as it says what it is on the menu...but it also seems a little weird that a down home restaurant doesn't have REAL fried chicken.
The slaw was disappointing and lacking flavor, the mashed potatoes were fine but unremarkable, and the mac and cheese was pretty good - probably the best side item. Be aware that dry lima beans are different from lima beans. Dry are very light brown in coloration, rather than green/yellow, and tend to blow up in size and get a starchy, almost mealy texture. Not as good as regular limas, in my opinion, and I didn't like that they were thrown on the plate with the chicken rather than in a small cup or bowl. The juices seeped all over the chicken fillet, which meddled with the otherwise crispy breading.
We split a piece of chocolate pie for dessert after the waitress raved about it. It might be a decent piece of pie if one had never had my mother's chocolate pie, but since I have...it was disappointing. The chocolate filling was very sweet and closer to a mousse, and the graham cracker crust was far too gritty.
I sound very critical, but there was nothing BAD about City Cafe. The prices are very good and the menu is quite varied. Just not sure I'd come back when I'm so accustomed to really outstanding home cooking!