Tommy C.
Yelp
City Tacos (B-)
Executive summary: "A" for vibe & decor, but food gets a "B-" only. Some of the tacos are good, like the "scallop taco" but others are plain boring, like the "carnitas". I expected better. Given Craft Taco is in the same area, also with a great vibe and better food, I won't be revisiting City Taco. Modern taco spots worth revisiting, ranked are: 1) Craft & Taco Lounge in Escondido 2) The Craft Taco @ SOVA. Lola and City Tacos, on the other hand, didn't make it to the list.
-----------------------------------------------------
Another taco spot bites the dust. Saw the great reviews for City Taco and took my daughter for lunch after her dentist appointment. We were both pretty excited by the awesome atmosphere & vibe. The space is simply superb, both indoor & outdoor space. They offer a very big taco menu, and so took us a little time to figure out what we wanted. And, by checking in via Yelp, we got a free quesadilla. Among three people, we got to try a pretty wide variety of tacos and other side dishes.
Guacamole with chips (B): Chips were light and crunchy but lacked the corn aroma of some better chips I've had. The guacamole was nice, appropriately seasoned with a pleasant savoriness, the tomatoes added a nice flavor contrast. For $7, I expected a bigger serving, but nonetheless, quite enjoyable.
Elote asado (C+): The seasoning was okay - a touch on the soggy side although nicely savory, but the corn lacked freshness, with soggy kernels.
Quesadilla (B): This was actually quite nice. The nice aroma from the cheese, with a touch of savoriness came through, but here wasn't enough cheese for the size of the tortilla.
Scallop dream taco (B): Generous on the scallops, nicely marinated - maybe a bit too salty - and balanced with a creamy sauce. Probably my favorite of all the tacos we tried.
Crunch time shrimp (C+): The shrimp was fried to potato chip-like, so it didn't have much shrimp flavor. Could have been any type of taco and when fried to that extent, it would have tasted the same. Rather bland and boring.
SDCA taco (B-): Flavor was decent, a savory smokiness, but the beef was so thin that you could hardly taste it, or even feel it once you start chewing.
Carnitas (C): The pork tasted a little gamey, and salty - that was it. And it wasn't as tender as I would expect. The carnitas from Chipotle tastes better!
Churros (B+): This was the highlight of the meal. Served hot, crunchy with just the right amount of sugar. The inside was a touch doughier than desired, so not perfect, but still very tasty.
Conclusion:
The food was not great, but also not bad. It's a great place to hang out, provided you pick the right tacos that you like. But Craft Taco is just around the corner, offering similar space, so to me, that would be the smarter choice.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Grading scale:
A+: You absolutely have to try this place, even if it's a big effort to get there and may or may not cost an arm & leg. Oh, and parking might suck pretty badly too so be prepared.
A: Awesome spot and worth the effort, say up to a 45 minute drive with painful parking and may cost an arm only.
A-: Very very good. 30 minute drive, a little pain parking. May or may not be pricey.
B+: Very good, and a little bit of driving is fine.
B: Acceptably good and a solid choice if in the area, but not a destination restaurant.
B-: Not bad, reasonable choice if in the area and it's difficult to get to a better spot.
C+: You're really hungry and want something to eat, this place won't make you foodie happy, but at least now, you're full.
C: Mediocre. You ate, and you're thinking "meh". Probably not coming back, but not bad enough to make you angry.
C-: Okay, that was kinda sucky. Not coming back but feeling a little pissed about the bad restaurant choice. Dummy.
D: WTF?! Would have rather stayed hangry. Hope this place closes down soon.
F: You're secretly planning how to get the place shut down without getting caught, and wishing your worst enemy has to eat from this place the rest of his / her life.