Coffee Tyme at The Bay

Coffee from Coffee Tyme is a daily must have! Everything is phenomenal from the drinks to the baked goods to the breakfast sandwiches! And the staff is super friendly & helpful! Huge thanks to Jade, Lexie & the rest of the team for always kicking off my days with caffeine & smiles!

Coffee is wonderful. I come to these stores whenever i’m at the beach for vacation. This is the first time i went to the one by the bay, but for years I go to the one at the Cape May Mall. I always get the frozen pumpkin coffee. it’s to DIE for. As for this store, the service was wonderful. Thanks to Jade! The atmosphere is so neat and clean and very well organized. Would recommend.

Very inconsistent flavor wise, but staff yesterday was very nice and welcoming. Got a matcha yesterday and it was pure perfection. The right amount of milk and matcha and vanilla syrup. The staff yesterday was very bubbly and super sweet and overall amazing. Got 3 today and they were all not a good consistency of what matcha should be or look like. There was too much milk today, but yesterday it was very pigmented and green and today it was very light. We asked for vanilla syrup but still only tasted like milk. I should have asked for them to be remade but I didn’t want to be a burden I could just add sweetener for the kids when we are back home.

Absolutely love this place! The coffee is always fresh and flavorful, and the staff(Lilly) is incredibly friendly and welcoming. Whether you’re grabbing a quick cup on the go or settling in to get some work done, the atmosphere is cozy and relaxed. They have a great selection of drinks and pastries—everything I’ve tried has been top-notch. Definitely my go-to spot for a caffeine fix!

I was so relieved to find out they sell whole coffee beans. I had Lilly as my barista and she was lovely and the service was fast. I had such a rough day and her kindness and positive vibe really turned my day around. I got the cinnamon twist and it is delicious. Highly recommend.

It was so exciting to have Coffee Tyme open out in Villas! The coffee was amazing as ever and the donuts were delicious and the super sized cookie is amazing! Love if and highly recommend!

What a great coffee shop perfect area very clean and the service is amazing. I was very impressed with the young girl there whose name I believe is Melinda I didn’t get her last name what a pleasant young lady always smiling and ready to help. Will be coming back with friends over this weekend.

Great coffee, and the service was excellent. We came to Cape May for a weekend and made this our coffee spot. The staff was very kind about our request to check the ingredients on every item, and answered all of our questions. Many of their flavors were kosher. The coffee itself is one of the best I've had.