Melissa S.
Yelp
They had me at "Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream." And that's all I needed to tell my family to convince them to roll out of Casper's and Runyon's Nook and continue to stuff ourselves with the best foods the Upper Midwest has to offer.
While Chocolate Shoppe in Madison has dozens of flavors, including more caffeinated flavors, non-dairy, and other specialty ice creams, Cold Front has some of the best of the best. I was in heaven scarfing down my Fat Elvis, while my family members enjoyed Zanzibar Chocolate and This $&@! Just Got Serious (a name which I hate, as if my opinion on that issue matters). The shop is super cute, and while we were happy just having scoops of ice cream, if I lived closed by I'd make good use of their sodas and coffee bar.
So why just 4-stars? Customer service left much to be desired. Sure, we were a bunch of weirdos coming in and ooh-ing and aah-ing over buckets of ice cream, but humor us here! One staff member dutifully, though with not much expression, doled out our ice cream while another person continued cleaning and stocking, which is fine--it's just they didn't seem to care that we were sooo happy to get our ice cream here.
Hopefully it was an off-day, and even if it wasn't, if we lived closed by we'd be regulars. If you serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream you could basically do anything short of poking my kids in the eyes and still get my approval.