Niki E.
Yelp
So Coles has been there before time, in my book LOL, Before I even knew what a bar really was as a young girl LOL, so for starters it stands the test of time, nobody's going to bring down Cole's on the Elmwood strip! it's here to stay from what I can tell and that says a lot right off the bat!
I've had so many memories here from brunch with my friends and the occasional stop in for Apple martinis in my 20s, Random dating event in my 30's in the bar area as well as mannnny stop ins over the years to get a warm meal when feeling a little lubed up from alcohol . It kinda hits everything you want here. It's a wonderful staple in terms of your locals, it's also a place to go after a good drink, and additionally if you're looking for breakfast lunch or dinner and you're an out of towner, Coles will meet your needs for everything--knowing that it is truly a Buffalo, NY staple! So don't forget it! . And also if you're into beer they have lots of it, all the finest beers, all different percentages, so if you're into that, that's all here at Coles as well!
But now in 2022 via GrubHub I ordered some of Cole's absolute finest haha, and by that I mean I just randomly ordered whatever I felt like ordering l! And STILL! it was the absolute finest !so thank you Coles, you always deliver the best! Even through delivery services! everything held up as if I was ordering it in the restaurant it was Fantabulous!
We ordered a lot of things tonight! The very first thing that hit my lips was the pizza logs! Now, as you know pizza logs are often found on appetizer menus but this girl right here .... has eaten a LOT of pizza rolls!! and I literally love them even if I'm ordering them from a crappy pizza joint!! so when I say these were the BEST pizza rolls I've ever had, I am not lying to you, I wish instead of four I had had eight and maybe just made that my whole meal!!!! Seriously!
I also randomly ordered an appetizer of onion rings and I'm sorry I don't know why... I don't know how.... I mean you really can't screw up onion rings-- but like especially delivered to your door, I don't know... there was just something about them, they were just like the best!!! I don't know, they were great, just like the pizza logs --give me more!
Okay so the hot banana pepper dip-it came with a generous portion of baguette sliced bread,
It's got this thick layer of cheese melted over but you got to get through that to get to the actual dip which is just you know phenomenal, again even via delivery! It traveled so well! and I could hardly eat it all yet I wanted to so bad! And it's just gonna make my tummy hurt if the do so I can't LOL but like definitely it's to die for and nooooo, not spicy at all, so don't worry about that!
OK now the Ruben, let me just say if you don't want to order anything else and you know you love a Ruben Bam! Done! you are good to go here! It comes with the most delicious crispy fries and of course your crispy pickle and the Reuban is exactly the way you want it to be ya know? the only thing I'm gonna say is if you like it drippy, if you like it really drippy-- don't forget to ask for a side of dressing, in my case maybe two sides of dressing!
All right now for the finale, so I am obsessed with shepherds pie. If you've never had it, I mean OMG....it's topped off with mashed potatoes ,what more can you ask for?! but there are different interpretations of the best shepherds pie right? so you really don't know what you're getting into it at just any old place! With Coles if ya feeling drunk an sloppy, we'll then Coles Shepard's Pie is a hidden gem for you!!!! To start it's got melted cheese poured all over it as it's base, followed by a mound of mashed potatoes and then all your classic Shepard's pie delicacies underneath!
I can't deny it's absolutely delicious, however I like a more classic classy shepherds pie, that doesn't need cheese to make the dish, it's all about the potatoes and the succulent meat and veggies underneath without the need for cheese, in my personal opinion. However a lot of people don't know what shepherds pie is and if you're not sure on one random drunken night---- I dare you! to order it ! and you will be thoroughly satisfied ! especially from Coles! I'd say it's like the equivalent of a garbage plate, but for dinner--ya know cause it's got a lil class on the side, ingredients wise!
Do you not forget to stop at Coles if you're visiting in Buffalo New York, it's been around long enough, and any of your locals will direct you here for sure!