Dan F.
Yelp
I really don't understand the negative remarks that I have read, but I guess everyone has an opinion and all of them should be respected. There were a couple of times that the Colonade Diners' politics were mentioned, and I have no idea what that means, I never got any vibe as to the place being left leaning or rightwing, but lets talk about the diners merits. I am a native Staten Islander from the north shore, and have been to just about every diner on the Island, they all have their strong points and weaknesses. My Brother, Sister and myself meet just about once a month for lunch, and we pick different spots to eat, and I can tell you that the Colonade is a top self diner. We have never had anything but exceptional service, and the food has always been very good. Of course there are times when you think something could have been better, but the spirit of the employees is always to keep us happy. Just as a little example, we went 2 days ago, and we were meeting for a late breakfast/early lunch at 11:00am. Well, as things go, we didn't sit until at least 5 minutes past 11, and we hadn't even thought about any breakfast specials. Well, when we sat, the waitress asked if we wanted anything to drink, and i ordered a diet coke. She then came back with menus and said that if we wanted breakfast that she would give us the breakfast specials, of which a coke isn't part of. Know what? She substituted the coke for the coffee that was offered as the special and called it even. So, she gave us the breakfast specials without us even asking, and then gave us a thoughtful substitution again without us asking. I know this review is painfully long, but i wanted to give a clear idea of the spirit of this diner. It's a friendly, accommodating place with real good diner food, and even better service. What more can you want?