Kate T.
Yelp
I visited Comet Coffee between a morning discussion and afternoon lecture. I wasn't entirely sure what to expect, since I had heard that it was very small and I wasn't sure if I would get a seat. Overall, however, there were plenty of spaces available, and I was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere. Described below is a list of what I really enjoyed and what I felt a bit iffy about.
Skip to the end for a summary if you don't want to read everything in between!
I enjoyed...
The ACTUAL DRINKS. I got the Forest Tea, which is an herbal blend of roots and green tea. It was mellow and pleasant, a great way to relax into studies between classes.
The DISH WARE. I received a bright orange tea pot with a matching cup once my tea was done steeping, which was absolutely adorable. I noticed that for mochas and similar coffee drinks, customers were given light teal and dark brown mugs with matching saucers. One man who ordered black coffee was given a plain white mug, which I also found very context-appropriate.
Cutesy drink = cutesy cup. Straightforward drink = straightforward cup.
The DECOR. The decorations included tea- and coffee-related accessories (including a kettle that I own and highly recommend, so I trust their authority), painted hipster deer on the window (partially what drew me in), and plants. The walls are a soothing mint green that complimented my teapot quite nicely. The lighting. It was soft enough that it didn't give me a headache, but bright enough to work comfortably.
The TABLE ARRANGEMENT. Two of the actual tables in the establishment were dedicated to no-screen interaction. I saw these tables mainly being used by people getting together for a chat or for scheduled meetings. Although it made finding seating a bit more difficult, I thought the concept was very fitting of Comet's hipster chic vibe.
The PEOPLE It was fascinating to watch the variety of people that frequented Comet because they weren't exclusively university students (wow, shocker)! There were art students taking photos, yes, and the girl next to me was doing some economics reading, but I also happened upon my History of Art professor, as well as a variety of men and women meeting over coffee or reading the paper. It was a breath of fresh air from the typical customer base of large chains like Espresso Royale or Starbucks.
I was iffy about...
The actual FURNITURE. I ended up sitting at the rightmost of the two benches lining the front windows. The seats were rather uncomfortable, as they were basically barstools with a lip on the back. They were cute, but the lip dug into my tailbone and made my experience slightly more uncomfortable.
The NOISE. I know that they can't control it in such a small space, but the acoustics were not great. The steamed milk screaming seemed even louder than usual since the walls are mostly bare, so there's no way to absorb or dampen the noise. Not a big thing, but probably not the place to go if you're looking to do some quiet reading.
The MUSIC. The fifties ditties they played may appeal to many audiences, but they were not my favorite. I appreciated them and their addition to the aesthetic in the first 20 minutes I was there, but they soon grew old. A quick fix, though, was to put in headphones, so I would recommend bringing some form of music if you aren't a big fan of old-timey music.
The LACK OF OUTLETS. I couldn't find any! I know that's it's encouraging a tech-free environment, but the situation was a bit inconvenient.
The process of MAKING MY DRINK. They steeped my tea for me, which may be convenient for most, but I have very specific preferences about how to make tea properly, and this put a bit of a wrench in my process. I'm sure, though, if you're like me and would like a bit more control over your drink that they would be happy to oblige. I just didn't ask.
TL:DR
Overall, I thought the vibe of Comet Coffee was very well-thought-out and cohesive. The people were friendly, the drinks were delicious, and the atmosphere was bright and energetic. Plus, it's a great location (in Nickel's Arcade). I wasn't as big a fan of the actual seating, the lack of accommodations for those working on laptops, and the acoustics. I would suggest Comet for someone who likes a more personal, hipster-y environment who might be working more on paper than online. It's definitely a niche spot.
Although I enjoyed my time there, I don't think I'll be coming back, simply because I enjoy a bit more space and a more traditional, college-y atmosphere, like Common Cup or Literati (reviews coming soon!). I would, however, strongly recommend the shop to anyone who vibes with the above lists. It's a rare, cute gem in the middle of Ann Arbor.