Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill

Bar · Sussex County

Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill

Bar · Sussex County

1

37169 Rehoboth Ave Ext Unit #6, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Photos

Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null
Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill by null

Highlights

At the revamped Conch Island, enjoy fantastic food, lively music, and unbeatable service, making it the perfect stop before or after hitting Rehoboth.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

37169 Rehoboth Ave Ext Unit #6, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971 Get directions

conchislandbar.com

$10–20 · Menu

Information

Static Map

37169 Rehoboth Ave Ext Unit #6, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971 Get directions

+1 302 212 5936
conchislandbar.com

$10–20 · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Mar 4, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Beach vibes wise, Rehoboth is about as far away from Key West as possible, but this Jimmy Buffet-inspired dive on the main drag is nothing but good times. The menu leans traditional pub grub with a sprinkling of southern Florida staples thrown in for good measure — think conch chowder and peel-n-eat Key West pink shrimp. The real draw here are cheap beers and a jam-packed lineup of nightly live music. Conch Island is cover band heaven. Be sure to check out Matt Avery — otherwise known as The Human Juke Box — on weekend nights." - Caroline Coral

Where to Eat and Drink in Rehoboth, Dewey, and Lewes, Delaware - Eater Philly
View Postcard for Conch Island Key West Bar and Grill

Mark Murphy

Google
While visiting family, I had the opportunity to visit this establishment for happy hour. Judging by the outside (strip mall appearance), I definitely was not expecting such a well decorated place, not to mention great food and drinks. The space is big and spread out, it is SUPER clean and beautiful on the inside. The happy hour menu was not only great and quality but it was dirt cheap, something I’m definitely not used to. $7 crushes and $10 meals. I had the 3 daughters burger which was cooked nothing short of perfect the way I asked for it. Was delicious. Others had the Buffalo Chicken Flat Bread, clams and sliders which they enjoyed. Our waiters were fantastic, fast, polite and personable. Played some great tunes and they have a very nice stage for live music. Also have neon signs lining the walls with famous lyrics. Do yourself a favor and stop in, you won’t be disappointed.

Mindy Alexander

Google
We stopped in after a long day of outlet shopping on our annual girls trip, on a Sunday evening. We were greeted by Mike, who had a long list of happy hour deals for us. We had a party of 8 but the service was so fast, it was like we were a party of 2! Mike let us know that there was live band karaoke that we should 100% stay for. This was an incredibly talented band, playing any song you could think of, with ease! The crowd was definitely a lot of regular locals, but the talent that came in was AMAZING! The food was top notch. I had a shrimp pasta dish, for $15!! So many Happy Hours deals (and happy hour didn't end until 7!) The Nacho appetizer was H U G E! Mike warned us it was definitely to share, but this thing was a mountain of deliciousness! Long story short, if you're looking for a great bar/restaurant with the best food around, at a great price point, awesome entertainment, this is it!

Robert Quinn

Google
Not a bad crowd for the Tuesday after Labor Day. They were hosting an open mic night, so always a crap shoot. We were in the area and stopped in. Nachos were just okay.

Frank Luchi

Google
Came in here to enjoy some music and drinks. The bartender asked if i wanted to start a tab. Nothing out of the ordinary. My phone goes off and it is my bank with a fraud alert. They charged my card $50.00 to open the tab. When I questioned the bartender, he told me that is policy. I asked, why was I not informed that they would put a $50.00 hold? He says "we are just busy, it is not a big deal, it will come off in 24 hours". It has been 24 hours and still shows. I understand putting a small hold on a card, but if it is going to be that big, have the common courtesy to tell your patrons! And the attitude as so rude, will never come to this place again! My money better be back in my bank today!

Nicole Sullivan

Google
The food here is fantastic and our entire family enjoyed our meals - especially the buffalo wing dip. We also enjoyed the atmosphere from the music playing to the cleanliness of the restaurant. Our server was nice enough and our orders all came out accurately and quickly. The one downfall that leads to my 4-star review is that out of the multiple bathrooms, there isn’t a single one with a changing station for a baby. They have a kids menu and high chairs, it would be nice to have a place to change my child. I had to hold my son in the air as my mother in law changed his diaper. If they added changing tables, this would be a 5-star rating!

Dana Harold

Google
We were here two days in a row. Excellent service. Every employee was amazing, but the bartenders were top notch! The food was great. We highly recommend it. Definitely will be back again.

Erin Papaleo

Google
Stopped into conch island after a day of shopping with a group of girls. We were instantly greeted by Mike who took care of us all night. Per Mike they make everything in house and it all blew us away. The crab cakes were the best crab cakes I’ve ever had. So light and delicious. We ended up staying for live band karaoke. Such a great atmosphere, amazing food, staff was super attentive and everything came out quick and fresh! Stumbled upon this place by accident and we are already planning our next trip back!!

Cyril Moore

Google
Not a bad place to grab a few drinks. We stopped in waiting for a table at a restaurant down the road. Overall prices were not bad. Got a $5 margarita and the wife grabbed ab orange crush. A fresh squeezed orange cocktail. Kind of a nice place to get a drink and chill for a little bit.