C B.
Yelp
I must have driven past this place, thousands of times, over the last few decades. Always considered trying the food but always worried about getting Chef-Boy-are-dee crap pizza from the dumpy looking place. So, yesterday, when i was stuck in Covid-Life rush hour traffic, I looked over from the Safeway parking lot, fully expecting the place to be gone. What happened was, I didn't recognize the street signage facelift that replaced the old aging 60's style signage that was there for oh so long.
Initially, my plan was to go to Jerry's at Four Corners, Silver Spring (only to find out that it's a GameStop now). But, thanks to all the 4-star average by 200+ Yelpers, I built the confidence to go ahead and go for it. However, I was still leery, due to all the recent 1 and 2 star reviews.
I have a rule: When in Rome, Eat like the Romans. In this case, the place is called Continental PIZZA--clue, try the PIZZA first. I walked in, looking for, nix, INSPECTING for any red flags, before dropping my precious money.
While the place may be a little outdated in décor, it's totally understandable. When you're busy making food for 5+ decades, since 1967, when do you have time to close the shop and remodel? And, if people are coming for the food, why spend money on aesthetics that only snobs would care?
I looked over the menu -- and even though, i had a taste for a sub in mind (or tummy), they have listed "Continental Pizza" and thought "When in Rome...". The Continental is mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni and onions and large for $11.10 in 2021--my thoughts were, must not be a very large "large".
I was told by the clerk that it would be 15 minutes, so I stepped outside so that other customers could come in (Covid-Life).
When I picked up my pizza, I couldn't wait. I ate most of it outside in the cold. What I will tell you is, for $11.10, that pizza was a great bang for the buck. The ingredients tasted of high quality and the crust was not (or did not appear to be) the delivery service, Sysco or whoever makes dough, generic.
I would not consider the crust to be thin nor thick. It was slightly crispy and a little crunchy yet a bit chewy with a heavier consistency which reminded me of fresh baked sourdough. The flavor was pleasant and subtle, not bland and not overwhelming--which allowed me to focus on the cheese, toppings, and sauce.
Honestly, I did not make mental notes on the sauce but what I will tell you is everything came together like a symphony for me that all I could think of is pizza bliss.
So, I ate this pizza hot, then i ate it cooled off, and finally, refrigerated cold. All high marks from me.
I would give this place 4.5 stars if we had halfs but rounded up this time - due to value on performance -- a strong pizza at a bargain price. The large square pie would feed 2 adults in my estimation. i asked myself, is this the best pizza that I would travel out of the way for, probably no. How many places can I name in the area that I think the pizza is better....In Maryland, maybe 5-6. So Continental is on my Top 10 Maryland Pizza, just not at the top of this list.
Price - About Fast Food cheap plus minus
Food Taste - Very Good to Excellent
Food Presentation - Meets Expectations
Service - Meets Expectations
Speed - Meets Expectations for fresh pizza.
Next time I go, I will try the subs and submit my report. Thanks for reading.