Matthew F.
Yelp
Before commencing my review, I caveat by saying that this was their soft opening and that it seems like management is serious about improvement as they become more established.
Visited during their "Beta Test" with a friend and was delighted warmly greeted and seated. What became apparent was how much effort they were putting into the retro video game theme; from the menu items to the "Rated M" hand stamps for adults attendees, to the gamerization of corporate terms like "Beta Test" for soft opening, it's clear how much effort they were putting in.
The dining area floorspace had a bar with TV's playing both sports as well as episodes of classic animes like Yu-Gi-Oh, and little lounge areas set up like parlors with mock game consoles set up and console gameplay clips playing on analog TVs. The arcade was mostly in the back, save for a handful of games in the dining area.
Being from Buffalo, NY myself, I ordered the Pilotwings and a local porter. The eight wings were dredged in a homemade buffalo sauce which was spicy and flavorful, although it was begging for some blue cheese which I was told they didn't have yet, and that they only had ranch dressing. They were topped with pickled carrots/celery which wasn't a bad addition.
My biggest grievance was how expensive my order was. Between the beer ($10), wings ($18) and tax/tip, the total came out to almost $35. Alexandria isn't a cheap city, and all for spending a few dollars more to support a small business that house makes its own fare, but over two dollars per wing without blue cheese (which I was told would be extra once they had it), and $10 for a beer that retails at $3 per bottle seems a bit extortionate.
As for the arcade: A system glitch meant that we had to reschedule for a later date, and they gave us some complimentary game tokens as compensation, which was greatly appreciated. I was impressed by the initial selection they had, including almost a dozen retro pinball games, Skee-ball, Pac-Man, space shooters, classic beat 'em ups, a few driving games (Crazy Taxi, my love! *All I Want by The Offspring blares internally*), and a number of light gun shooters as well. And holy hell, was I humbled remembering how difficult many of them were.
Granted, not all of the promised titles are in-house yet, so I hope they'll have able to add some more driving, FPS, and other retro titles like Dance Dance Revolution soon. I am a bit concerned if/how they intend to expand their game selection or floorspace, given that the current layout is rather compact and it doesn't look like they have the room to add much more.
Overall, this place certainly has potential, and you can see the love and passion behind its conception and execution. I just hope management is willing to address some of the growing pains this soft opening is bringing to light. Hopeful to have the chance to stop by again soon.