Cookie Crave & Creamery

A welcome new dessert spot in Wallingford! The cookies have a very homemade vibe to them, which is nice. They mostly sell familiar classics like chocolate chip, peanut butter, and molasses, but there are also a few unique flavors like fudge thumbprint, lemon chip, and salted caramel. They also offer a gluten-free vegan protein cookie which is surprisingly tasty. They sell ice cream (packed to-go or by the scoop) from Olympic Mountain Ice Cream. Overall, everything I tried was tasty and the owner was very friendly! Grab a dozen for a good discount.

I thought the cookies were very good, and the ice cream is outstanding! Try the Madagascar Vanilla - it is so vanilla-forward and absolutely delicious. Very cute shop - very small. White chocolate chip cookies and the peanut butter were both great.

The lemon chip cookie with lemon glaze is one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. Perfectly gooey and delicious crispy edges. I didn’t want it to end! The owner Tim was fantastic too! Looking forward to bringing a batch of these to my next dinner night with friends.

Truly the best cookies i have ever had!! Warm and ooey gowey on the inside and the perfect amount of crispyness on the edges. The staff were so kind. Their ice cream is also really good and not overwhelmingly sweet. An overall 10/10, definitely recommend!

Their chocolate chip cookie was so good. Warm and gooey inside yet outside was still cripy. They also have interesting flavors of ice cream. Will try it next time!

Cute little spot and there was a great variety of fun flavors! The cookies were soft and warm- we tried the lemon, brookie and pumpkin and they were all delicious!

We were excited to try but sadly it was pretty disappointing. We tried four different cookies - nothing looked / was displayed that well and the cookies were not uniform (some super flat, others dense and high). Everything tasted ‘ok’ but no better than anybody’s homemade attempt.

We’re so excited for this place to open! We had the opportunity to taste the cookies pre-opening, and they are incredible! Be sure to stop in for a freshly-baked cookie, and better yet, take a dozen home with you!

I noticed Cookie Crave Creamery driving to/from Wallingford. After a chocolate chip cookie chat with another Yelp Elite, it was great timing to stop by on 11/7/25. I was able to glance around as other customers were being assisted. Bright, well appointed retail and production site. Well stocked glass case with assorted cookies and a freezer off to the left with pints and larger ice cream containers. Terrific to see that the cookies are produced and baked onsite as the open production area is viewable behind the main counter. I selected two each of the chocolate peanut butter and chocolate chip macadamia cookies. Back at home, these were deemed really fresh and tasty. After another long time cookie retail site closed in Wallingford, it's great to have Cookie Crave Creamery. Welcoming service, convenient business hours, and reasonably priced cookies, ice cream, and ice cream sandwich treats - an all around win-win!

I stopped by Cookie Crave and Creamery on a Sunday afternoon. It wasn't busy, but it was clear they'd had a good day as many cookies were already sold out. The staff member was very friendly and took the time to explain the different flavors. The shop itself is small, clean, and cute. Note that there is no seating; it's a grab-and-go style store. My favorite thing is the cookie size. They're smaller than a typical gourmet cookie and also a bit cheaper ($2.5/cookie), which is great because you can try multiple flavors. I tried three: The Brookie:This was my favorite! It's the perfect, chocolaty combination of a brownie and a cookie. Sugar w/ Brown Sugar:The brown sugar topping added a pleasant, nutty taste to a regular sugar cookie Lemon Glaze: A solid, standard cookie that's exactly what you'd expect. It's a great choice for anyone who loves a sweet and sour combo. What stood out across all three was a distinct, rich, buttery flavor.

We noticed the Cookie Crave Creamery was new in town on our walk around the neighborhood after dinner and decided to stop in. And... wow! What incredible friendly service from the owner with delicious cookies to match the great experience. We left with 7 cookies and a pint of ice cream. You can imagine where our night went. You can't make a bad decision here but the red velvet cookie really stood out. We will be back!

Picked up some cookies while waiting for my take out nearby! Caught a fresh choco chip cookie coming out of the oven. Amazing!!! Definitely will be back for more!

Stopped here for a cookie yesterday and it was delicious. Small cute store, friendly & helpful staff. Always nice to have more cookies in your life!