Cosimo's Italian Restaurant

I stumbled upon this place since I was planning on going to Yestercades across the street with my brother and my daughter. I was able to find street parking and it was free since it was past 6pm. The restaurant is so beautiful and they had outside seating. We chose to sit inside. The lady who greeted us when we walked in and sat us at our table was very friendly. Our server (I think his name was Dave or something similar) was polite and professional. He brought us some water and warm bread. We ordered the lasagna, baked ziti and pasta Alfredo with chicken. Everything was absolutely delicious and filling. We unfortunately didn’t have room for dessert. Our server was kind enough to pack our food in to-go containers for us and it was absolutely delicious the following day. I highly recommend this place and can’t wait to go back.

Stepping into Cosimo's on Board Street in Westfield was a great choice. The food was absolutely delicious, starting with the warm, crusty bread and butter—I could have made a meal out of that alone! For our mains, we ordered the penne rose pasta and the eggplant rollatini. The penne sauce was incredibly decadent and rich, and the rollatini was also very good. While the restaurant offers plenty of seating, be prepared for a bit of a parking challenge. Overall, a fantastic meal in a great location.

The food is amazing and excels in a town with many options to choose from. The crispy calamari is well seasoned and the perfect appetizer to have. The focaccia sandwich is, by far, the best value you can get with a decently sized sandwich and high quality ingredients. Unfortunately, the interior is tired and dated with a lot of the furniture being very worn out. The service did not match the quality of the food with our waiter being non-existent for long periods of time after we ordered. We sat at the very end of the restaurant and had to flag down a busboy to get help. As bad as it may be, it didn’t detract from how immaculate the food was.

My family celebrates all our special occasions here. The food, service, and atmosphere is outstanding. I love cosmos, it’s our family sit down and take out place. Don’t walk, run to cosmos. You won’t regret it. Love it!!!!!!!

PROs- 5 star location, food, service , price CONs- parking ! I rarely give a 5 star and this one deserves it . Went for a bday eve and it was really good . Location is good . Lots of other restaurants nearby. Parking is a bit crazy . We had to park a couple of blocks away and take a 5-7 min walk. Parking is generally free after 6 pm . Even if not it’s too expensive. About 50 cents for 30 mins . Service was good . They give bread and butter to start with and it was fresh . My kids had pasta .. 🍝 really awesome ! We also tried pizza 🍕 and it was tasty. Lots of veggie options . I had Panzenalla salad . 🥗 very fresh and nice proteins .. five cheese ziti was super good . Mozzy garlic bread was so good . To end it tiramisu .. I actually didn’t like it much . It was ok. It was still a very good experience.. kudos to the whole team .

Big portions, tasty food, quick service - what's not to like? 😁

I was super underwhelmed which is disappointing because I had their catering at a birthday party and loved the food. We ordered takeout on a Friday night. The honey crispy calamari was soggy and the portions were so small. The bolognese sauce had flavor but was watery. Bread was hard.

Has a Birthday lunch today and every aspect was above my expectation! I was absolutely impressed with every detail and everyone in our party fully enjoyed their meal! We will be visiting and having celebrations there in the future! Our Waitress was exceptional and we will be back!!