Cozie's Pizzeria & Cafe

I recently visited a neighborhood staple, and I can tell you I was not disappointed! They have a great menu and have frequent specials that are delicious. I tried the calamari, garlic knots, butternut squash salad and a plain slice all of which were amazing. The staff and owners are so sweet I even had the chance to chat with one of them! This is a place I’ll visit over and over the pizza is one of the best in NY! The word “cozy” in the name describes it all for your lovely local pizza shop! They even had a cool birthday wheel 😎

Cozie's is a neighborhood staple, and our kids LOVE their pizza! Max, the owner is a great guy who truly understands what it means to be a neighborhood pizza spot. Whether he's giving our kids trinkets from the quarter machines or hooking up our school with a discount for pizza parties, Max is a great pizza guy and Cozie's is a great establishment! Oh, and we've order pizza from here several times for our kids' birthday parties too, and he always delivers on time!

The pizza is delicious. The vodka slice is good. The chicken roll is amazing. Service is good. Staff are professionals. Cozie's pizza & Cafe is highly recommended.

The atmosphere is like a good pizza shop from the 80s and 90s. The pizza is absolutely delicious! My family and I have been ordering from the same pizza place for years on our annual ice skating day, but I told them to try cozies and no one was disappointed! We ordered 7 pies (all different) and each one was better than the last! It's definitely our new go to for pizza on ice skating day and every other day!

Wow! Just WOW! Wish I had gotten here sooner but won't be long before I come back all the way from NJ! Sicilian Crust was perfectly cooked. The MVP may be the best pie idea ever! And to top it off we tried a butternut squash salad and it was excellent as well. Super friendly and welcoming place and staff! Don't miss this one if you are in the areas!

This is your everyday's neigborhood style New York Style pizzeria. Pizza are very nice, but it's a little bit pricey, but overall this pizzeria offer great quality of foods. Has to take a star off because of price factor. (Sorry guys, but really the price of even a regular slice is almost the same as some of the great and the most famous Pizzeria at nyc in Lower Manhattan area?)

We ordered the Margarita, garlic knots and antipasto salad last night. The Magrarita was SO BAD- I don't understand. The dough tasted really weird, and there was an insane amount of uncooked dried oregano. And there was WAYY too much crust compared to the rest of the pizza which made it worse. The garlic knots had almost no flavor, and the antipasto salad was inanely weak.

Oh, YES! Just YES! Go here. I ordered delivery & first off, this ‘medium’ pizza is huge. I got the vodka bacon pizza and garlic knots. Everything is a flavor bomb and delivery came 15 mins earlier than the app’s estimate.

This place is a neighborhood gem. The pizza is good and the folks who work there are absolutely lovely. Highly recommend. Tip: their weekday lunch offerings (non-pizza) are also excellent.

Pizza slices are good, but the chicken parm sandwich was very dry (barely any tomato sauce or cheese) and on focaccia instead of a sub roll. Recommend sticking with the pizza!

10/10 pizza!! definitely recommend going it's worth it best pizza I've had in a while, im so coming back, the pizza is just too amazing the staff was so nice aswell props to them!

I've been going here for years. it used to be good. Now it's GREAT! it really changed when new owners took over a couple of years . Not only is the pizza great but they have some amazing salads & side dishes. (try each at least once!$ This is our go to pizza place in this entire area.

I used to only ever crave Prince Street Pizza, but now I can't stop thinking about Cozie's. You won't find a better pizza joint in the neighborhood. Maybe even in all of Brooklyn. The folks there are lovely and really take care of their guests. The perfect spot to grab a delicious slice and relax across from the park. If you haven't had Cozie's you're missing out.

Can't say enough about how great this place is. Ordered several different meals for my family and everyone loved what they got. Ordering was super easy, everything ordered was correct and fast delivery too. It's a great go to option on those nights you just don't want to cook. Highly recommend

I love the pizza here. It is very good. It's tasty and the crust is crunchy and well made. The service is good and the ambiance is usual of a pizza place. They also have seating outside, but inside, that's attached to the restaurant. They have vegetarian options as well. The only thing is, I ordered a Caesar salad and they brought me regular greens and no Caesar dressing. I am allergic to arugula, so I couldn't eat it, after waiting 20 minutes for the salad. When the cashier asked the cook if they have romaine lettuce, he said no. So, then why advertise Caesar salad? Anyway, just be careful ordering this salad.

Cozie's is well hidden in Windsor Terrace. I went after a friend suggested that I try it. I ordered two Margherita slices and they were good. Not the best slices, but pretty good. I will try them again.

Great nyc style slices served from warm people. Great for the kiddos. Love the way they slice it for them.

The best! Margarita pizza is great. The people are super nice. One of the best pizzas I've had.

Best vodka pie in the city. MVP is solid too. Kindest team making pies in the neighborhood.

After the reopening the pizza doesn't taste as good as it used to. Although they got new furniture and outdoor seating but it is enclosed. I'm hoping they uncover it now that the weather is warmer. They also expanded their menu which I'm nervous to try because of the decline in pizza taste. Also they raised their prices.

Very disappointed with this place. I have ordered a few times since it's the local pizza place and is not what it used to be. Today is the last time we will order. Since we're not fans of their pizzas we ordered a few heros - instead of bread they used their pizza dough. This was not a hero. Sorry to say but we will not be ordering again.

This is the newest pizzeria and Windsor Terrace and wow-- it's the best pizza in the neighborhood. The crust is crispy, the sauce well-seasoned, fresh cheese & toppings. As I write this, even though it is early in the morning, I am making myself crave a slice of their fantastic pizza! Did I mention the crust was crispy? The price is slightly higher for a pie but I guess that's what it cost to get pizza of this caliber. You know, with crispy crust.

We got the margarita pizza last night. Delicious! Crust was outstanding, great sauce and seasoning. There has been a lack of good pizza places in Windsor Terrace, so this is a welcome treat. Our new go-to.

Pizza in name only. Undercooked, very greasy. Much better places very close to spend your pizza dollars!!!

I've been meaning to write this review for a long time . This is by far the best pizza I have had in NYC, hands down. First, there's the variety: Upside down slice? No more trekking out to L&B, they do their own version which is just as good. Grandma? Margherita? They do it here and it's amazing: nice crunchy crust, with the freshest cheese and toppings. Even a pepperoni or cheese slice is great, and again, the crust has that nice crunch. Not to mention the fact that Max and his staff are very kind and accommodating, plus, there's a new enclosed porch with tables that has doubled the seating area. I wish this place was here when my kids and I would spend an afternoon in Greenwood Playground or getting together with their sports team for a pizza party--HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Best local pizza joint in Windsor. The pizza is great. Especially the vodka slice. I highly recommend it.

I had the pleasure of stopping into this place today for lunch. The service was amazing, Max and the staff was attentive, so friendly and provided prompt service. I purchased the chicken parm hero and it was delish. I definitely will be back!!!

I'm giving it a 3 for the pizza I tried was pretty good. Much better than i expected. I only tried it twice and very good.The square , I think it had pesto and something else was delish.Someone compared it to L n B which is a big stretch but I'd go back . Server was very nice n I wish them good luck

Nice improvement over Little Toninos. New owners and better food quality in this neighborhood staple next to Greenwood playground