Amol U.
Yelp
3.5
It's so refreshing to see a legit craft beer spot back again on the Upper West Side (RIP, Beer Shop). Sure, there are a bunch of other bars around here, but their craft selection is the stuff you'd find at most convenience stores. Craft + Carry, on the other hand, has some decent pickups from breweries from the NYC area, plus some harder-to-find cans and bottles from further out.
There's a good mix of different types of beers available on tap or for purchase, though not quite as large a selection as some of our other favorites, like City Swiggers (UES) or City Beer (Murray Hill). If you don't feel like going out of the way to those locations, though, this is a solid local option to have. If they cycle their inventory often enough, we'll definitely be checking them out on a regular basis.
The pricing could definitely be better. Most of the cans start around $7-8, which is generally on par with other NYC bottle shops. Sometimes, though, it was quite off the mark; for instance, we found a Grimm's sour for $20 here that was $9 at the UWS Trader Joe's, and a few of the KCBC cans that are $8 here can be found nearby at Whole Foods for $5. In short, you could probably do better if you cared to on recent releases from local breweries, but otherwise the prices are fair-ish for the rarity / convenience!
To round it out: cool space, really friendly service. Will be back!