Crazy Susan's Cookie Co

Can we give more than 5 stars? Wow! The best cookies and fun varieties to delight. Visited on a busy Memorial Day Weekend. The staff are fun, funny, and give out free laughs. Cookies are 10 out of 10. Delicious. Thank you Crazy Susan's for doing it great and having fun while you do it. We will be back again!

Every year we go to the Ocean City NJ shore we spend time feasting on the various culinary delights. Crazy Susan’s cookies are one of our favorites. They have a large variety of cookies and it’s hard for me to identify a bad one. My personal favorite is likely the Turtle Caramel cookies. But you really cannot go wrong with any. And Susan is a wonderful person and does everything she can do to support her customers.

As soon as you walk in, the smell of the shop, the hospitality of the staff, and the plethora of different flavors will let you know what type of experience you'll be in for. Decided to try this place yesterday because we drove by on the way into the city. Met some of the nicest people I've ever had the pleasure of purchasing something from behind the counter. Let us know what cookies were top sellers, what was fresh, and even went through the trouble of packaging certain cookies separately that may have affected other cookies that were in the same box as it. On top of the great service and pleasant conversation, these were seriously some of the best cookies we've ever tasted! The chocolate chip is perfect, the boardwalk is something unique and delicious, the mint chocolate was tasty enough for me to enjoy a flavor I'm not typically a huge fan of, just to write about a few of the flavors we tried. I seriously recommend swinging by if you have the chance. Everything was so great we had to stop by today too, and I do plan on ordering online in the near future. Thank you guys for the one of a kind experience!

Crazy Susan makes some amazing cookie varieties! You don't want to leave the beach without paying her shop a visit. 😋

Great staff who is kind and friendly. They are wilto always help and explain how their cookies are made and will package them separately for you. There isawide variety of flavors. They are all good. They are large cookies. I have always enjoyed my visits.

Try the “hot chocolate” chocolate chip cookie. So soft and moist and melts in your mouth. Tastes just like hot chocolate. Chocolate chip cookie lovers will not be disappointed. It’s out of this world!

Ordered on-line to be shipped. Received assortment. Cookies were dry, no moisture, hard, and unfortunately tasteless. Huge disappointment.

Went In for the first time ever this week! The couple who owns the store do it all and the are the kindest, genuine people. Cookies were yummy. Comparable prices to a Crumble cookie but so much better. We got a dozen for about $26. We were not huge fans of OCNJ but the cookies were a favorite!