Ashley F.
Yelp
I first heard of this place through facebook. A friend shared a food blogger's photo of the crab pie, and I knew I HAD to try it. My expectations were VERY high, and unfortunately, I was a bit let down. I happened to be in Baltimore already, so I figured it would be a good time to try it out. It's on the top floor of a mall(?), and parking is a bit weird. They tell you to park in a loading zone, turn your hazards on, then go upstairs to get your food. I ordered online, but from what I understand, it's supposed to be prepared when you get there, so expect to wait a few minutes. It's a super cute shop and has a great view of the harbor. Everyone that I encountered while there was very nice and welcoming. I told the young lady at the register that I was here to pick up an online order. She popped her head in the back and told the chef. I sat down to wait, and 10 minutes had gone by. People that came in after me were getting their food before me. I continued to wait. Another lady (maybe the owner/manager?) asked me if I was waiting on something. I told her that I've been waiting on an online order, and I checked in about 10 minutes ago. She went to the back to see what was up. Apparently the chef never heard the young lady tell him that I was there. Maybe they should have some type of confirmation between FOH and BOH. I ordered the crab pie and the pumpkin snickerdoodle cookies. The website has a picture of two pies, but the description says "pie," as in singular. I called to confirm. You get one pie. When I got to my car, I decided to dig in. Now the crab pie is $16. A little pricey, but the claim of it being "stuffed with blue lump, jumbo, and colossal crab," I could see past the price. Either they were having an off day, or their claims aren't true. The pie was a bit on the smaller side, and it was lukewarm. The crust was good, and the filling was disappointing. Overall, it was just okay. The filling was minimal, and I didn't see/taste lump crab meat. I tried the cookies next. They weren't wrapped up very well. There was a bit of parchment paper, but they sort of just jumbled around in the bottom of the bag. When I think of snickerdoodle, I think of a soft, chewy cookie. These weren't that. BUT the flavor was absolutely delicious. I didn't taste pumpkin at all, but the snickerdoodle taste was very good. I'd definitely get them again. I'm kind of on the fence about whether I'd return. Like I wouldn't go out of my way to make it there, but if I'm in the area, I'd try different cookies and maybe a biscuit. Those did look good.