Karen S.
Yelp
This attractive, friendly shop is more defined by its spirit than the quality of its teas. The herbals and rooibos blends are fun, and where Cup of Tea can outshine its Portland competitors. When it comes to straight-up tea leaves, the quality, in my opinion, is noticeably inferior to Tao of Tea and Smith. Put simply, the more you learn about tea, the less you will be impressed here.
While I really like the broad selection and enthusiastic employees, I have to take issue with their herbals, too. My favorite so far is the delicious Unicorn's Bargain (complete with tiny sugar unicorns!), and the Chocolate Orange makes a good dessert tea. But I tried their seasonal Candy Cane Lane today and, after trying their Earl Grey, it's my second disappointment.
The problem is that they can get too outlandish and throw everything and the kitchen sink into their blends, resulting inevitably in a sum that's less than its parts. Candy Cane Lane contains: apple, peppermint, coco, lemongrass, liquorice root, eucalyptus, blackberry leaves, yogurt granules, pineapple cubes, natural flavoring (?), marshmallows, whole star anise, red currants, and pink cornflower.
WOW! That sounds amazing! It smelled great. But it's way too many different things and meaninglessly expensive for the flavor ($5/oz). I have in my cupboard some lemon myrtle from Tao of Tea that cost $2/oz. It tastes almost identical, plus mint. Two or three cheap herbs would be less than half the price, and yet there is very little difference between them. You only needed peppermint and sweetness to produce the flavor of a candy cane.
What bothers me most really is the price tag here. Can I taste pineapple, apple, or yogurt? No, but you can bet they increase the weight of the tea, whereas a purely herbal tea would get you many more cups for the weight.
I want to believe that that owners just get overexcited mixing things up, rather than that they focus on presentation over flavor. Having just shelled out for Christmas gifts of this pretty and aromatic but disappointing tea, all I can say is if you're getting more than a couple ounces of tea, try before you buy. You never know what you will get with Cup of Tea's crazy blends.