Mike L.
Yelp
While looking into what restaurants we definitely had to try during our time in Monterey and Carmel, one name kept coming up among the recommendations from family and friends alike - Dametra Cafe. Whether it be about the food, the vibe, and just the experience as a whole, nearly everything we had heard about this place was more than a little positive. Of course, that was before seeing the sheer volume of positive reviews for them on Yelp! So, as much as I tried to avoid it, I'd be lying if I said I didn't come here with some lofty (and hopeful) expectations!
Initially, as we first walked up to the door, the restaurant didn't seem all that large (the host stand is a small counter right by the door), nor did it seem very busy. However, not only did it fill up quick, but it's actually a lot more spacious that I thought, with enough room for them to even bring out music instruments and get folks (including us) to dance with them during the middle of the dinner service. Similarly, the menu is also surprisingly extensive, both in terms of the number of dishes they have and the range of cuisines it spans - Italian, Greek, Spanish, Lebanese, French, and even Syrian. It's not always a good sign when a restaurant covers that many, but we had faith based on everything we had heard. Plus, I can't say we minded having so many choices to pick from!
-- BABA GHANOUGE - Fire Roasted Eggplant Mixed with Garlic, Lemon, Olive Oil, and Greek Yogurt with Pita Bread...$13.95
I usually opt for hummus, but I'm glad we got this. The baba ghanouge had a nice mix of flavors (I especially liked the hit of garlic it had), but the taste of the eggplant wasn't overpowered either. Plus, the consistency was perfect - thick enough to stay on the pita bread, but not chunky either.
-- FRUTTI DI MARE with Mussels, Clams, Salmon, Snapper, and Shrimp in a Light Garlic Pinot Grigio Sauce over Spaghetti with Garlic Ciabatta Bread...$39.95
Ironically, I wish this had more pasta because this had a ton of seafood! The salmon and mussels, in particular, were great, but I wish the snapper hadn't fallen apart (it tasted dry). Also, I loved the taste of the ciabatta bread, but the edges were really hard/crunchy/
-- GREEK STYLE LAMB SHANK - Six Hours Braised Lamb Shank Topped with Lamb Au Jus Served over Potatoes Au Gratin and Vegetables...$36.95
First and foremost, plus points for portion size - the shank was huge! However, while it did fall off the bone, the lamb wasn't as juicy as I would've liked. The au jus certainly helped, but it was also fairly salty. Funny enough, the star of the dish was actually the potatoes au gratin - genuinely, the best I've ever had!
-- BAKLAVA - Layers of Phyllo Dough with Chopped Nuts, Syrup, and Honey...$Free
Not sure why they comped this (maybe because they roped us into dancing?), but I'm not complaining - it was great! The layers of phyllo dough were crisp and the filling layer of the fillings in between were both delicious and not terribly sweet.
As far as service goes, all of the different servers who helped us, as well as the host (manager?) who stopped by to check on us, were terrific. They were all very friendly and made us feel super welcomed (it felt like they were genuinely happy to have us there, unlike another restaurant during our trip...). Between that and the fun and lively atmosphere (we saw lots of folks walking by stop to look in when they were playing music and singing), eating at Dametra is just as much about the experience as a whole as the food itself. Which is a good thing because, while our dishes were definitely above average, they didn't impress as much as I had hoped for. Then again, all of those preconceived expectations undeniably had something to do with it. I'd still come back, though I'm curious about other places too.
THREE AND A HALF STARS for the food, but rounded up everything else.