Robert G.
Yelp
Updates for East Side long running restaurants - 1 of 2
I'm glad that this restaurant, DeNicola's, is a constant. It truly anchors the generous, tasty, and filling Italian restaurant niche when so many newer Italian locales are going trendy, expensive, and skimpy. (I'm looking at all you pissy, self-regarding bistros that pop up where the cool people who think they are discerning tend to live.) In fact, their sandwich board outside mentions that, if you like 'East Coast Italian food,' you're a shoo-in for DeNicola's.
The interior continues unchanged and they keep it in nice shape. Take note that the restaurant has been handed down a generation and you will see a portrait of the proprietress in addition to photos of the founding generation. Here, the clientele is down to earth and so are the employees.
I ordered one of the things I often get - the tortellini filled with meat in a white sauce. The portion size was to my liking since I can almost inhale filled pastas. With it came a dinner salad, some antipasto items, and a bread basket. They are sticking to their good things and one of them is the delicious pesto salad dressing.
I'm going from 4 to 5 stars because, on the last visit, the young lady who was the server for my table did an outstanding job and was very amicable and enthusiastic. Since I've been here a number of times, I still look back at the one-off time that there was this really friendly hostess who reminded me of Judith Light. You remember her, right? She was the female lead in "Who's the Boss?" That celebrity lookalike was the hostess, hence she got you seated and such, but she didn't take your order ... but she had this great vibe. So, both that hostess and now this energetic young lady really ratcheted up the quality of the visit and I'm going with 5 stars.
So, in closing, I'm coming full circle. It's this 'East Coast Italian food' characterized by good taste, good portions, and good value where DeNicola's delivers and I'm very glad I dropped in to have dinner.