Ali F.
Yelp
We came on a Sunday night prior to going to zoo lights, and I was pretty excited because I love their sister restaurant, Coda di Volpe. I was looking forward to some pasta and had been eyeing the garlic knots on the menu! While the food was overall good, I don't think it is worth the price. The service, despite it being somewhat slow, was not the best either. And the cocktails, while seeming to have high end ingredients or fancy combinations, were just super expensive, small, and generic tasting.
We started with those garlic knots and I was so excited when they came out. They looked almost like parker house rolls covered with garlic butter. They were served with a small side of red sauce which was well seasoned and delicious. But while the outside of the rolls were soft and fluffy, the insides were dense and chewy, in a bad way. I was pretty disappointed in these small tough rolls and they were $8 for 4 of them. A bit steep considering garlic knots are supposed to be made out of discarded dough. I have no clue what they do to these garlic knots to make them so weird, and apparently the tough inside is a feature not a bug since many people have reviewed them saying the same thing. We also shared the house italian salad, which was delicious and hit the spot, but a bit small for $11 considering it was just iceberg lettuce, a few veggies, and dressing. It really reminded me of Olive Garden's salad, which I absolutely love, but double the price and very bottomed rather than bottomless. I considered ordering another one because it was so small but we just waited for our entrees.
While we were greeted quickly and apps came out fast, we had to wait a while for our entrees which was fine, but the couple of times our waiter stopped by he did it in such a rush that we had to flag him back down to order another drink (which was empty when he went by, he was just inattentive). We ordered the Sunday special of Chicken scarpariello ($36) which was boneless chicken thighs, sausage links, and a metric ton of peppers. We also split the Orecchiette ($26). Both entrees were tasty, and we were impressed by the flavor and tenderness of the chicken. However it was only two small chicken thighs, and I feel like for the price there really should have been at least one more chicken thigh in there. It was disguised as a large entree because there were probably about a pound of cooked peppers included on the dish, but the pepper to meat ratio was way off, probably 5:1 of the meat which was just unbalanced. The Orecchiette was also delicious, tasted like a standard dish you'd get at any italian place so nothing particularly special. It was probably the most reasonably priced of our dishes and I still felt like it could have been a bit bigger.
So while everything was tasty, the value just wasn't there. The cocktails are $16-17 for pretty standard drinks, and I think that's just ridiculous. Then the last thing that really bugged me was that our server dropped a dessert menu at 6:50, and he didn't come back until 7:10. We wanted to order dessert, but we had 7:30 zoo lights reservations so we ended up skipping it. We didn't see him at all during this time, and despite us trying to make eye contact with the manager, or SOMEONE to get our server so we could get dessert, no one seemed to notice. So overall this was a nice place but I think you can get similar tasty food at a much better price elsewhere in the city. For 2 cocktails, the "garlic knots", a salad, and 2 entrees, we ended up spending over $150 which was too much considering we didn't even have leftovers. Would have been 5 stars with better service and prices.