Erin G.
Yelp
We had been to multiple weddings at Benachi and we loved the space and had heard good feedback from our friends who utilized it, so when we got engaged it was our first (and last) stop. The price is certainly more affordable than the majority of New Orleans venues, as we've become such a destination wedding city at this point. But it's not a "cheap" spot by any means (off-season Friday night event was $2,250 after taking out the refundable security deposit). What you do need to realize going into it is that Benachi is a largely DIY venue. If you want someone to hold your hand and plan your wedding for you, this is not the spot for you. They provide tables and chairs and a basic sound system. Otherwise it's on you to figure out the rest (catering, bar, linens, ceremony music/PA etc.) Personally, that's what we wanted, so it worked well for us.
James gave us a thorough tour and let us do some wandering around the grounds on our first visit. Rhoda was personable over email and very friendly the day-of. We didn't ask for any help from the staff really, because we didn't need or want it. The wedding party set up everything (tables/chairs for the reception, ceremony chairs, sound system, decorations etc.) and we were happy to be left alone to do it. There is an option, however (for a small fee), that you can give the staff a layout of how you want the tables and chairs set up and they will do it for you if you're really just not into the idea of doing setup yourself. I did ask for some lightbulbs to be replaced as there were many that had burned out in the front "birdcage" where our ceremony took place. James hopped up on a ladder while we were getting everything else ready and replaced those for us with no issues. The ceremony was beautiful and the reception went well for the most part.
As is mentioned in other reviews, the requirements for music are a pretty large bummer. The neighbors seem to be reasonably awful and they essentially don't want to hear a peep from the venue, so it would take some clever setup (probably having the "dance floor" inside or in the driveway) to be able to really have music of any volume going on. I know the owners of the venue are looking for solutions that will both respect the neighborhood and allow party/wedding hosts to actually play music at a danceable volume. I'm just really sad that didn't happen before our wedding. We're both very musically inclined people and we worked for months on a personally curated playlist of our favorite tunes. I had quite a few of my fellow dance krewe members at the event, so we expected a fun dance floor and we simply didn't get to have that. Like, at all.
In the end, however, aside from the music we had a very positive experience at Benachi. What we wanted was a beautiful backdrop that we could create our own atmosphere in and that's what we received in spades. We all had a great day of setup and I will always cherish those hours of building centerpieces and hanging decorations with my favorite people. If you're in the market for a beautiful and historic spot to throw a lowkey wedding or party, I couldn't recommend Benachi more highly. If you're a fussier type who wants everything done for you, there are other venues in the city that will better suit your needs.