Amanda L.
Yelp
This place used to be Dino's Coney Island & I heard that the owners were looking to switch things up, so rebranded, remodeled, & reopened as a cookie dough bar! Such innovation :)
I've been meaning to try this place for years now, because I really love cookie dough, and I can't believe it took me this long to finally try it! The concept is just delightful, albeit probably a bit too modern for downtown Rochester's overall vibes, but regardless - I thoroughly enjoyed it!
They have so many varieties of cookie dough options, more than I thought existed, & operate the same way an ice cream shop would. You pick your flavors & how many scoops you want & they scoop it all up and package it for you!
Keep in mind though that one scoop of cookie dough is way more dense & rich than a scoop of ice cream is, so if you can't handle your sweets like I can't & just unfortunately have a much smaller sweet tooth than you wish you did, I'd recommend going for the kids cup. I made the mistake of ordering a normal scoop of cookie dough and barely made it halfway before I had to quit because my throat was burning from the overwhelming sweetness! Obviously, it's nice because - unlike ice cream - you can pop this into the fridge when you get home and finish it the following day as well, so it doesn't go to waste :) But I would say plan for getting less than you'd normally expect yourself to eat because it overwhelms the palette much quicker than you'd expect!
BONUS: There's still a little walk up window at the back of the shop where you can order your breakfast, lunch, and/or dinner coney island cravings, which I think is so smart! :)