Dinotto
Deli · First Settlement ·

Dinotto

Deli · First Settlement ·

Sandwiches, deli, take-n-bake, wine, gelato, and dry goods

muffuletta sandwich
siciliano sandwich
southsider sandwich
quality ingredients
great bread
friendly staff
imported italian goods
arancini
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null
Dinotto by null

Information

106 S Webster St, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
LGBTQ friendly
Trans safe

Information

Static Map

106 S Webster St, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

+1 608 285 9021
dinottomadison.com
@dinottomadison

$10–20 · Menu

Features

•Credit card accepted
•Debit card accepted
•LGBTQ friendly
•Trans safe

Last updated

Jan 14, 2026

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2026 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,992 Cities

Chicago’s bar and restaurant closures for 2019 | Eater Chicago

"An Old Town institution that operated for 30 years across three neighborhood locations, Dinotto closed over Thanksgiving weekend; enthusiasm is already building for a replacement pizzeria from chef Gianni Gallucci, who will bring traditional Neapolitan pies to the space and is expected to open in mid-January." - Eater Staff

https://chicago.eater.com/2019/1/30/18204664/chicago-restaurant-bar-closures-2019
Dinotto

Gavin H.

Google
I was feeling nostalgic for Italy today. The main takeaway from my time there was the food. So when I heard about this little sandwich shop I was very excited. The atmosphere of the shop itself is small and quaint. I ordered two sandwiches. The Muffaletta and the Siciliano. The staff was very friendly and quick to make the sandwiches. The Siciliano was what I expected. It was delicious. The Muffaletta was also good when it came to the quality of the meat and cheeses. Sadly my only complaint would be the bread was stale. It may have been day old considering I was there right near opening. Other than that it was a good experience. The shop has a small assortment of imported Italian goods for sale. Cheeses, drinks, and pastas. I would definitely return again. Not like the food I had in Italy but a good American version of it.

Randy W.

Google
Ordered the muffaletta and the chicken parm, and both were delicious! Great bread, meat, cheese, and condiments. Large enough that you might want to eat half now and save half for later. For an east sider having Dinotto takes the sting out of losing Al***ri to Monroe St.

Tu C.

Google
I tried the Southsider for the taleggio cheese. Very tasty with high-quality and fresh ingredients. The cheese wasn’t too funky and the bread was soft with enough crunch in the crust. Will definitely come back!

Ethan p

Google
There was almost 3 fingers thickness of meat on my sandwich, at first when i picked it up it didnt even feel like a sandwich just solid like salami. It was incredible, the meat was not too salty and the bread had just enough oil without being greasy.

Jay Bob I.

Google
Genuinely fantastic and I've been around the block, figuratively and literally. I've only tried the muffaleta, but it was 10/10 and just a salty pile of amazing. I mean I wish it was cheaper, but genuinely worth it based on the quality and portion. No photo because it was gone by the time I remembered to take a pic.

Amanda B.

Google
The Southsider is the best combination of balanced, delicious, flavorful ingredients I've ever tasted on a sandwich. Perfect. Thank you!

Joe M.

Google
Got the Siciliano sandwich. Great bread and tasty meat. Also got a frozen eggplant lasagna to heat up.

chrissie V.

Google
Absolutely delicious and fresh! Convenient location one block off the Capitol Square!

Suz W.

Yelp
I stopped by D'Vino but they were closed for lunch and recommended that I try their deli around the corner. It was amazing. I had arancini stuffed with meat and peas in a fabulous lightly spicy marinara and a tangy farro salad. The food was fresh and quick. Next time I want to try the muffuletta sandwich.