Andrew C.
Yelp
I'm somewhere between a 3 and a 4 for this Dogfish; if I could dole out a 3.7 I would. Were my expectations too high? I'd been drinking Dogfish's brews for going on 20 years now, so maybe.
Anyway, after I found myself in Delaware recently, I made a beeline for this legendary brewery, situated in a dark, modern, blocky building with a stylish outdoor patio set a couple of blocks off Rehoboth's main beach. Walking in you face a nice bar area right next to the windows; a few steps further and you're inside a large, unassuming room with tall ceilings and a proper stage for live music at the back. To the side you have a series of booths against the outside wall, with very cool round windows looking onto the street. That's where you wanna sit, but alas, we got sat in the big room by ourselves at a small cafe table, which just wasn't very sexy - it was like we were a couple of truants doing time in a warehouse. Our server was efficient and seemingly indifferent, but then millennials are like that (oh no you didn't!) and that's not a dealbreaker for me. Annnnyway, I don't have any other broad generalizations up my sleeve at the moment, however, the food was also only so-so; my turkey burger was a bit on the dry side, though tasty and filling enough. The beer, as I'd hoped, brought everything back up to snuff, with my choice of Hazy Squall IPA saving the day, and the menu seems fairly deep for a brew pub, with burgers, salads, pizzas, tacos and more. I bet this place is absolutely rocking when there's a band playing or it's prime time, and I'm sure the energy level is off the charts then. But as it stands, our lunchtime visit just didn't leave me doing backflips - it was simply an average Monday afternoon lunch in a very nice place (the outside patio seemed way nicer though) with excellent beer. Very good, sure, with lots of beer (and merchandise) options but not a destination in and of itself.
Would I come back? Maybe. The merch store next door is pretty fun.