David K.
Yelp
The way pizza should be! They get so many things right: The crust is of perfect thickness: not thin so it tears easily and all you taste is toppings, and not thick so you can't fold it in half. Neither dry nor oily. It's stretchy like a pizza crust should be, not crumbly or bread-like. No annoying cornmeal stuck to the bottom. And not burnt; just nicely browned and toasted in spots. Regardless of what some shops seem to think and have fooled many diners into believing, crust burned to carbon-black is NOT a good thing.
I could go on. If I had to dock any points on the crust I might say it was a bit heavily salted. That wasn't really a problem for me - I love salt - but might be objectionable to some.
I did not order a traditional pizza but rather one of their specials, "The Appalachian". Sausage, caramelized onion, aged white cheddar and goat cheese over an apple butter Base. An intriguing combination that really works. You don't really taste the apple butter as an apple or dessert flavor; rather it comes across as another dimension of sweetness that works really well with the caramelized onions which were expertly slow-cooked and nicely brown and caramely. Goat cheese with its salty tang offsets the sweetness and of course cheddar and apple pie are a classic combination so the cheddar works with the apple butter. The sausage was thinly sliced, mildly spicy, and fairly abundant.
To add to the many positives they cook the pizzas in that beautiful wood-fired oven that features prominently in the interior decor. The wood oven and the open kitchen add another whole dimension of interest to what would otherwise be a fairly ordinary sports bar. Given the choice I'd much rather watch the kitchen activity than the telly, yet another gang of overpaid men running around throwing balls and chasing each other.
I wish I could have tried an ordinary tomato sauce and mozzarella-style pizza too for comparison purposes. My specialty pizza was terrific but unique so it is hard to compare with other shops. Surprisingly, they don't seem to offer standard combinations like pepperoni and mushroom on the menu, but all the ingredients are there and you can easily "make your own" for a reasonable price. (That's what the DW did and ironically she ended up with something very similar to mine, minus the apple butter. She liked hers too.)
Also surprising: the a-la-carte toppings didn't include many common ingredients which I really like, such as hamburg, meatball, and eggplant. They would need to offer these to get 5 stars from me.
As to the service: we were seated quickly, our waitress was great, and the food was cooked quickly and perfectly, with no mistakes. Excellent service to go along with the excellent food.
They also have a stage and apparently have live music several evenings (except - naturally - the evening we were there). Looks like a good place to hear music and worth checking out. Though for my musical tastes I am probably more suited for the Floyd Country Store, nearby, which seems to be their main competitor on the Floyd music scene.