Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Visit this restaurant for a meeting with a friend. The atmosphere is very pleasant, plus the style of decoration is cozy. I really loved the customer service and the performance of the waitress, dynamic, punctual, attentive. I recommend that you do not make the same mistake as me, my visit was on a fish Friday and I went for this one, a serious mistake that fish was a dish not at all recommended, do not try it, fish is not its forte. I tried pasta and yes I loved it.

I’ve been in Bay View over 30 years and had always loved this pizza but today’s was terrible. They charged me $24 for an awful pizza. Taste is not the same, missing cheese covering only part of the pizza. The quality of the ingredients has changed. We will not be back

Ordered a larger pizza over the phone. Should have been around $24. Was told they can’t do larger pizzas and instead would do two smalls for the same price. When we arrived to pick up they handed us one small pizza for $40(not the price we were told). I asked where the second pizza was and they eventually found it. Pizza had very little toppings on it and the crust was burnt. Not worth the price they charge.

Just like the days of my youth. Pizza is phenomenal. Price was a little higher than expected, but the quality was there so I can't complain much.

First of all, I want to say that this is my favorite pizza I have ever had. I've been going here since I was born, and I have never had a bad experience. My go-to order is an Italian salad for an appetizer, and for the entree, a sausage mushroom pizza with pepperoncinis. It has always been a pleasure to go here, and I would like to thank DeMarinis for all the great times!

Food was tasty! Hot and ready fast. The onions were charred black. That was surprising and unexpected. There was only one other table when we got there and 5 more after. That did make the waitress a little slower coming back for anything.

Pizza was expensive and over done. Could have thrown on a few more toppings for $28. They need to update their price list too. I was surprised when the pizza was way more than I expected. Judging by my order there's a cheese shortage in Wisconsin. Not the De Marinis I knew.

We've been going to DeMarinis since Mama first opened decades ago. The pizza was always great. Incredible fennel seasoned sausage, great crust. Sons Dom and Phil continued with the same recipe at their restaurants on Lake Denoon and Bay View. We just returned for the first time in a couple of years. The pizza is flavorless. The fennel has been removed from the sausage and the crust is soggy. Phil still owns it but I think his kid has taken over. Probably trying to skimp on the family recipe to keep prices cheap. Which they are. Used to be one of the great pizzas in Milwaukee. No more. Not by a long shot.