Kelly C.
Yelp
I swear, we have a love/hate relationship with this place.
Been coming here since we moved here in 2020. We keep going back because we'll, their pizzas are awesome. But the service... it's either great, or holy crap, it sucks. I'd say 75% of the time, it's fine/passable. But the other 25%... tsk tsk tsk.
On our most recent trip a couple of days ago, we ordered their lemon pepper wings (as we always do). Holy crap, they were SALTY! Like you take a bite, and then your lips start blistering because of how salty it is. I know I'm pretty sensitive to salt, but these were "special." Over the top salty. Husband inhaled a wing ( he was starving) and then said "Wow, the wings are salty!"
So we told our waitress that the wings are inedibly salty. We told her the kitchen can just send us 5 wings, seeing as the husband ate one and took a bite of another one just to make sure, and I had tasted one wing.
The waitress brings back 5 wings. Evidently the cook just refried the old ones, then added MORE salt! They were even more salty than the first version.
She came back to check on us (kinda/sorta). She said "Everything good?" as she was walking away. I had to stop her and let her know the wings are completely thoroughly absolutely inedible. She said the general manager can come to our table. I said nah, not worth getting the GM involved.
We asked for the check and saw that we were charged for the wings. The waitress said that's why she offered to get the GM involved, as that's the only way something could be removed from the tab. I said never mind, it's a hassle and we'd just pay for it.
Well, I guess the waitress spoke to the GM and was able to remove the wings from our check, so thanks for that. We left her a ~25% tip.
The pizza (the Big Apple) was delicious, as always.
Really wish the service here would improve. We go ~3-4 times a year but would go every month if we knew their service is more reliable.