Diana B.
Yelp
You might guess by my reading this is not my favorite restaurant. Reed had made a reservation in advance, but you sit in the window by first come first serve basis, so why bother with the reservation?
I had a glass of Shaumsberg Champagne, at a mere $26, as it was my birthday. No comps here and no free dessert on your birthday. we ordered a dozen oysters to start from Tomales. Bay and the big ones were delicious and the small ones were salty.
I had read the menu in advance and was excited because it said they had Cioppino, but they didn't have it any more. Their menu online was not up to date. Dang! I ordered trout and Reed ordered a ribeye steak.
As you can see, by my photo, the tail and the head of the trout were burnt, Black. The potatoes look like they were falling out of the sliced open stomach and the fish was mushy. The sauce was to be a combination of capers, eggs, and lemon. It did not taste good. I actually could not even eat it. Between the potatoes, falling out of the stomach, the burnt ends and the mushy fish. It was a bad choice for my birthday. I took two bites and called it a night! Reed's ribeye had lots of gristle, and though it tasted fairly good, there was a lot of waste.
So it's my 74th birthday, I don't get to sit by the window. Enjoy the view and my dinner is awful. What a way to spend your birthday. We went into the bar and had a couple scotches . I should say we had one each to the tune of $60.
They did comp my dinner, but I would hope so as I did, could not eat it and even though I was excited for dessert by this point in time, nothing looks good ! Hooray, for bad birthdays! Go somewhere else....