East hampton sandwich Co.

Strolled in on a Saturday mid-afternoon only find the place deserted. The staff behind the counter are finding it challenging to choose between their cell phones and taking my order but I had patience and waited for some type of human interaction. I started with the Red Pepper and Gouda soup ($4.95). Great flavor from the red peppers. They really shined through but lacked basic seasonings such as salt and pepper. Next up was the $18.95 Lobster Roll. It's really a lobster spread like salad. I am using the term lobster loosely here because there was not much of it given the price. Not giving up on their sandwiches yet, I ordered their Fried Chicken and Jack sandwich ($9.95). Now the disappointment hit me in my face. Compared to the Hungry Petite (see mouthwatering pic), my sandwich looked like a mistake. The chicken was over fried leaving the meat dry and chewy. The bread to meat ratio was very lopsided. The bun was way to thick. At this point, although history has taught me better, I left with a bang and ordered the Charlie's Donuts ($4.95),- filled with chocolate, blueberry, and strawberry. You get one extra that has no filling but has a sugar and cinnamon coating. When I took a picture of them I could not wait to eat those. They looked great but as soon as I took a bite of them I felt meh. They are not sweet and flavorful. The fillings taste odd - just weird. Needless to say, none of them got a second bite. So bottom line: over-hyped and overpriced.

I have been dying to try EHSC since an ad of theirs appeared on my Instagram’s Timeline. I intended on trying the Lobster Sandwich, which I should have, but opted for the Meyer Lemon Chicken, Corn&Shrimp Chowder, and the Ginger Pear Lemonade. I love the ambience of the place; very bright and definitely inviting. Service was great. The Front End Clerk (Cashier) assisting, was friendly and had a warm smile. The cleanliness of the restaurant is superb. Now on to the food... •Corn & Shrimp Chowder.... Delicious soup but unfortunately the shrimp was over cooked as each bite was rubbery. The Chowder itself was deliciously seasoned. •Meyer Lemon Chicken... What could have been a very delicious zesty shredded chicken breast went awry when the chicken was overcooked. The condiments on the sandwich definitely added a flavorful taste. For a second I asked myself “Did I order Turkey?” I love that the chicken is shredded but my jaw muscles were worked overtime eating the Chicken. Overall I was still about to enjoy the sandwich. However, all hope isn’t lost. I will definitely come back here as it wasn’t bad enough to say ”that’s it, never again.”

The food here is amazing! I had their Hot Birdie sandwich with sweet potato fries. It's probably my favorite sandwich now. Everyone there is really friendly. Even though you pay at the counter when you order, they still come by and check on you. It wasn't too crowded and the food came out fast. It's a great lunch spot.

I was so sad when I finished my lobster roll. 😭 It was indeed delicious. The chips come with the roll. Plenty of parking and there are other sandwiches to try. Can't wait to go back and try the grilled cheese!

Great sandwich place. Lots of options and a higher tier than your quick cold cuts sandwich shop. Friendly staff, reasonable prices, and good food. I tried the spicy fried chicken sandwich and it was great! Side pesto salad was amazing. I would buy a jar of just that if I could. Acoustics are a bit rough. Crying babies just echo throughout the whole place as if they are right next to you.

Fresh delicious food in a pleasant atmosphere. I always get the turkey bacon avocado sandwich here, and for something simple it's fantastic. They make their bread fresh here and its outstanding. The staff is always super nice, and they have wine and beer as well. Pro-tip: get the sweet potato fries as your side, they are AMAZING.

I was really hungry this Sunday and so looking through Uber Eats and nothing looked very good. I had never heard of this place but the sandwiches looked very creative. When the order arrived it was still hot and the sandwiches were fantastic! Each one was very different. They were all sort of basic but also sophisticated at the time. I can't wait to go back and order some more menu items!

Very nice sandwich shop. There were 4 of us and each purchased a different sandwich, and we all loved our sandwich. Counter order, and they bring your food to your table. They have beer and wine, and self serve fountain sodas, tea, lemonade and juice. They have tables, benches and a more intimate seating area for dates and such. They also have roomy outdoor sidewalk seating for pleasant days.