Mike D.
Yelp
I was hesitant to try Easy Pie for two reasons. First, some of the reviews here on Yelp. Second, their menu is gigantic, and I figured there's no way they can have such a big menu and still be good.
Despite those reasons, I tried it anyways, and I'm extremely glad I did. And I've been back for it multiple times.
I've only had their pizza, but every pizza I've had from them was delicious. Not just delicious, but creative as well.
The Mac Daddy pizza tastes like, obviously, a Big Mac. It's one of my favorites: some tang from the thousand island sauce and pickles, a big pile of lettuce to brighten it up, and a nice helping of ground beef.
The Any Given Sunday is a close second. Think "chicken, bacon, ranch", but instead of ranch, it's honey mustard. It's not so much honey mustard where that's all you can taste: it's a softer note that gives you that flavor without overpowering everything else.
The desert pies ("sweetie pies") are a creative addition to the menu. I've tried the "Top of the Heath"... a great balance of sweet and salty. Was a little sticky to eat, but what can you expect from a pizza covered in caramel?
All in all, I'm a big fan. I can't comment on the service, because I've always ordered it for takeout.
Note that (at least on Uber Eats), it says that a small pizza feeds 4. This is wrong, it feeds 1. It has 4 slices, but it would absolutely not feed 4 people.