Eataly Caffè - Hudson Yards

The pastries and cappuccino are really good. However, the service setup could use some improvement. There is a single line for all orders, whether you’re just grabbing a quick coffee and a pastry or something more involved, like a hot sandwich. During peak hours, especially with heavy tourist traffic, this creates long waits that can be frustrating for locals or anyone on a tight schedule. Adding a separate line for quick orders or a grab-and-go section would make a significant difference. It’s a great spot — it just needs a more efficient service flow.

Of course it is overpriced. Out of all things ordered only chocolate mousse cake slice was decent. Cannoli is overly sweet and also the mini donut looking thing as well. Latte was bit lukewarm.

It's lovely! We traveled to NYC and stopped here for some lunch. They have a variety of options, plenty of room, and super friendly staff. They are busy at lunchtime also. We can pretty much find everything in here, such as pizza and hoagies. They also have wine and ice cream.

The food is so-so. The coffee is mediocre. The cornetto was quite sticky and somewhat dry, although the pistachio filling was pretty good and somewhat compensated for it. It's a bit expensive for what they offer. The best thing they have is the ambiance.

Great vibes for an Italian breakfast with cappuccino and pastries, or Aperitivo with excellent Spritzes! The view of Vessel is spectacular and there are plenty of seatings. Pizza and panini are excellent options for a quick lunch too

If I could rate it zero, I definitely would. I bought a Panna Cotta dessert, and the strawberries on top were moldy. Please see the attached picture as proof. I emailed to request a refund, and they told me my message was forwarded to the store—but no one ever followed up.

Amazing amazing AMAZING! I haven't had food this good in a while. Everybody was so sweet and so nice to me. Definitely recommend to come back here. The bearded guy with the arm tatooes that served my food was so sweet it gave me butterflies in my stomach.

My husband and I came up to NYC from South Carolina to explore, and we had great service thanks to Juan, the bartender. He was incredibly friendly and shared great recommendations about local attractions and hidden gems around the city. The drinks were very good too we loved the Limoncello Spritz and the Sicilian Old Fashioned , which was amazing very well balanced and different from your typical old fashioned !

Perfect lunch spot for a delicious Italian sandwich. It gets crowded at lunch so get there early to avoid the chaos of the line at the deli counter. Worth the wait though! Good price for the portion.

Ordered their specialty hot latte featuring their chocolate. It came as an iced latte and took quite a bit of time. They seemed overwhelmed. It was good, but just not as chocolaty/ what I expected.

I was attending a conference at the Javits center nearby so decided to grab lunch at Eataly Caffè since it had just opened the night before. The restaurant has a much smaller footprint than the full sized Eataly markets but does provide the perfect space for a quick casual lunch. The line at the food counter was lengthy so I grabbed a seat at the bar to order instead. The high seats were comfortable and the bar top was a beautiful white marble. Only suggestion here would be to add hooks under the bar to hold bags. The food offered at the bar was different than what was at the food counter. For my drink I got a La Nostra Limonata from Lurisia. This was significantly smoother than it's San Pellegrino counterpart. Maybe there is something to using three different lemon blossoms harvested in three different seasons for flavoring. For food I got a sandwich with mortadella, buratta and pistachios drizzled with EVOO. Presentation was excellent as it arrived on an impressive Eataly branded wooden slab. Mortadella was very delicate and seemed to almost melt in your mouth. Bruatta was fresh and flavorful. Bread was light and tasty but was perfect to let the inside components shine. The combination of it all with a satisfying crunch from the pistachios made an unforgettable sandwich. I also sampled a scoop of pistachio gelato on a mini cone which was complimentary as a part of their opening celebration. It was creamy and had a strong pistachio flavor. I'll likely return here in the future when I'm in the area.

$18 for a slice of pizza, guys? Are you freakin' serious???? I got a slice of mortadella and burratta pizza, and honestly, it was nothing to write home about. If it had been $5, it wouldn't have been so bad, but $18? Please!

Briefly, the best iced tea in Manhattan. Excellent baristas. Exceptional coffee bar manager. The seating is attractive but just adequate. (The table is too low for laptop use). Spacious, overall. A pleasing cafe to take iced tea and pass the time.