AJ M.
Yelp
Many a Yelp reviewer speaks about the proverbial "family-owned secret", where the smallest place can pack a big, flavorful punch.
Not today, my friends.
I walked into El Borrego De Oro expecting honest, affordable, and rustic Mexican fare. What I happened to get wasn't a surprise, nor a bad meal. It was just plain disappointing. For a place that is named after the animal that bears this favorite Latino meat, I'm sad to say that this joint definitely needs a good shock back to reality.
Although the place appeared to be packed, I found that the restaurant itself only seats about 15 people, and seemed to be seating even less due to the poor service. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, the service at this place is just outright nonchalant, even at its best. The waitress had us wait until a party of two left their table (mind you, a table for 5-6 people) and proceeded to seat us at the dirty table. She then took about five minutes to clean up, followed by a 10 minute wait for menus.
When I finally received my order, I had been through both my complementary chips and a long conversation with a friend. That being said, the food arrived, only to more disappointment.
The barbacoa was lukewarm, and tasted too gamey, much more odd than my other samplings (including my experience in Durango and Mexico City). The consome I ordered had the same odd taste, and had absolutely no seasoning apart from salt. Both items could've been complemented with basil and oregano. It certainly didn't help that the waitress came to badger me about the broth when I hadn't gotten through half of it.
Alas, I was not done. In the middle of my bland food, entered a rather unsolicited pair of musicians. After one terrible song and ten minutes later, I had to leave due to the fact that their portable Roland amps had left me with a splitting headache. Not to mention that the management and restaurant team didn't notice, or really cared about the fact that an obnoxious performance took place in the tiny restaurant.
====
Final Verdict: The only unsung hero was the fresh-squeezed orange juice. Thus, a 2/5. Will not be coming back.