Stephen K.
Yelp
I went tonight to celebrate my anniversary and had made a reservation before hand. Valet was pretty easy; I drove up to the hotel next to El Gaucho, a valet got my phone number and texted me a link for me to click when I was ready to get my car. Gave him the key and went over to El Gaucho.
Nice atmosphere, it was fairly busy, has almost a smoking lounge-type feel to it, a little on the dark side (which was nice). We were seated within a few minutes, and there was a happy anniversary card on the table (on the reservation I specified that it was my and my wife's anniversary).
Our server was very courteous and prompt throughout. Started with drinks and bread, both which were tasty. Also started with the crab cakes, which were awesome.
Next up ordered the french onion soup and table-side made Cesar salad. Some of the best french onion soup I've ever had.
After that got scalloped potatoes and the El Gaucho steaks, got them medium. They arrived perfectly, some of the best steak I've ever had. Perfectly medium, with a nice sear on the outside. Very melty. It's absolutely how steak should be done. Potatoes were rich and the cheese they used was very delicious.
We were offered dessert, which looked fantastic, but we just didn't have room. We were also given a complimentary fruit, cheese, and cracker plate, which was a nice compliment at the end of the meal.
I read the reviews so I was a little nervous about service, but tonight it was excellent. We never waited very long to be checked on, and the front host, our main server, and another server all made comments on a happy anniversary. In total we were there about 2 hours. All told, after automatic gratuity (which was completely earned), it was about $310.
If I had to nitpick...the lobster medallion on the steak was a little small, and we only got one round of bread. But again, that's nitpicking, that's me trying hard to find something not 100% positive. I would absolutely go again. I've been to the Michael Jordan Steakhouse at the Ilani a few times, and I think the steak here was just a bit better.
Oh, and when we went to leave, it was easy getting out. Clicked the link that the valet sent on my phone, we only waited a couple of minutes before they pulled up our car. It was $18 for the 2 hours we were there.
Overall I was super impressed!