Jenni A.
Yelp
My experience with Elderly was less than terrific. I was impressed by other reviews, their selection, and prices so I ordered a new ohana ukulele, with free shipping. It came very quickly, on a Saturday even, and it was extremely well packaged. Sounds great, right?
But the ukulele itself looked like it had been a floor model, or was b-stock -- it didn't look new. I could have overlooked most of it, but not the chip. Granted, it was quite small, but still, a chip.
I e-mailed right away explaining about the chip (with a picture attempting to show the chip) and requested a refund. I might have requested an exchange but I checked the site where it was stated the model was no longer available, and I was disappointed enough not to want to go through it all again.
The response was very quick and courteous, but I wasn't happy with what I was told, which was that certain imperfections should be expected. I don't consider a chip -- an actual missing piece -- an imperfection.
I was offered an exchange (maybe they didn't check if they still had it in stock before quickly responding, which I can understand), but was told that since imperfections should be expected, there was no guarantee that a replacement ukulele would be in any better condition, and that there might even be more imperfections. If I wanted to return the item, I would have to pay for return shipping. Or, I was also given the option of keeping the ukulele at a nice discount.
I appreciated the effort, but 1) I didn't want a damaged ukulele, and 2) I was annoyed by having a chip characterized as an imperfection.
As I was filling out the return paperwork I noticed it stated that I might be responsible for the shipping costs to me as well as the return shipping cost. I wanted that clarified so I e-mailed again. Again, the response was quick and courteous, and I was told there was a possibility I would be charged but in all likelihood, I would only be responsible for the return shipping.
I thought it was the best I could hope for and I wanted to get the matter resolved as quickly as possible, so I returned the ukulele. It cost me about $14.
I tracked the package delivery and waited a few days beyond that, but I didn't receive an e-mail acknowledging the receipt, or stating what their determination was as far as how it would affect my refund, or when I would be able to expect a refund credited to my account. So I e-mailed requesting status of the return -- again, quick and courteous response, saying that I would be refunded the full purchase price and that I could expect the refund in 7-10 business days (which I did).
So that's my story.
I will say that their customer service was very professional and responsive, and they were very good in their efforts to offer reasonable options given their policy. But I disagree with their position that a chip is an acceptable imperfection for an item purchased as new.
And I wouldn't say I would never purchase from them again -- because never say never, and I really, really love buying ukuleles -- but I would have to seriously consider and reconsider the risk in light of this past experience.