Corey K.
Google
My wife and I dined at Elemento to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary. I mentioned the occasion when booking, not because I expected special treatment, but to give context to the experience.
We were contacted ahead of time to confirm our reservation and told we could arrive early as the restaurant was not very busy. In hindsight, that set the tone for what turned out to be a quieter evening than expected for a restaurant of this caliber.
We chose the tasting menu (€95) with the wine pairing, though my wife preferred ordering à la carte—and in retrospect, she may have been right. The setting itself is excellent: sitting at the bar watching the chefs cook over an open fire is engaging and well designed. However, on such a slow night, the experience felt slightly awkward at times, with long pauses and little activity behind the counter.
The tasting menu leaned very heavily toward seafood. There were multiple raw seafood bites, followed by two warm seafood mains that, while featuring different fish, were prepared almost identically. The lack of variety made the menu feel repetitive. One of the warm dishes included a fennel salad that was actually the most memorable element of the course.
The standout of the evening was the wild boar main course, which was genuinely excellent and easily the highlight of the meal. In fact, it’s something I would happily order again from the à la carte menu. Dessert consisted of two courses, the final one being a very rich take on an ice cream sandwich—so rich that neither of us could finish even a small portion.
We also opted for the wine pairing (€65 per person). While the wines themselves seemed good, the pours were extremely small—around one ounce each. Between the two of us, we likely consumed the equivalent of half a bottle for €130, which felt difficult to justify at this price point.
One small but noticeable detail was that after nearly every course, we were asked, “Was it good?” or “Did you like it?” While attentiveness is appreciated, the repetition became distracting, especially given the expectations that come with fine dining.
Regarding the anniversary, I don’t expect special gestures, and I understand that pairing menus can limit flexibility. That said, placing a small candle meant for a child into the dessert felt awkward and would have been better omitted altogether.
Overall, while there were moments we enjoyed—particularly the setting and the wild boar dish—the experience didn’t quite meet our expectations for a restaurant positioned at this level. If we were to return, we would likely order à la carte and choose a bottle of wine instead of the pairing.
PS
-I must have missed the Videovigilância notice, but thank you for letting me and all future guests know that they will be under video surveillance while dining at your restaurant.