Kelley T.
Yelp
Fellow apartment hunters. I spent four years living at The Elements, from Thanksgiving 2020 until late 2024, & let me tell you, this isn't your average "pros & cons" review. This is a dive into what living here is really like, beyond the pretty demo units & the initial promises.
In 2020, moving from a 30-year-old unit downtown, The Elements felt like a dream. Newer building (built 2009), close to VTA, seemingly great amenities, spacious apartments & a great pandemic rate. I even scored a larger place with a full-size washer/dryer for just $40 more a month. Gabriella, my leasing agent then, was fantastic. Unfortunately, that's where the initial shine started to fade. It became clear that "teamwork" at Greystar properties (who owns The Elements, & many other older, "should-be-affordable" complexes in our area after acquiring Alliance Residential) often means a cliquey, tight-knit group that, seemed more interested in hanging out & partying hard after hours than ensuring consistent, honest resident service. Every agent after Gabriella seemed to do nothing but badmouth her.
My first year was a lot I was promised hardwood floors in my unit & ended up having to fight my way up the management ladder just to get anyone to listen.
Fast forward to 2021, & there was a management overhaul. While the first manager wasn't great (just check other reviews!), the new staff seemed okay. Then Joseph O. arrived as Assistant Manager (which ironically has a review for the Elements & response from manager), eventually moving into the complex himself. Around this time, staff seemed to constantly shuffle new management, new maintenance, even a resident temporarily.
During this period, The Elements seemed to unravel. The constant, negative reviews you see about crime, security issues, & non-working cameras? Believe them. They are 90% spot-on. There was tons of vandalism, especially in 2023 with a series of break-ins. It was only after these incidents that they decided to install cameras, which, ironically, always felt like they were more likely to be used against residents than to protect them.
Don't fall for the glossy positive reviews or the beautifully staged demo unit overlooking the pool (with those sneaky painted accent walls!). If you're thinking of renting here, demand to see your exact unit. Seriously. Your experience will vary wildly depending on where you're located in the building. If you dare to paint your walls (even if they approve it), get that approval in writing, because you'll have to pay to return them to their original color regardless.
My hardest personal battle here? Navigating life as a single mom, enduring constant noise from neighbors (even being criticized for trapping & neutering 12 feral cats to control the colony, something I did before moving out last November!). But nothing compares to the unimaginable grief of losing my 3.5-month-old child while living here. Dealing with that while trying to maintain my tenancy. Despite my unimaginable circumstances, their "sympathy" seemed to evaporate quickly when it came to rent. I fell behind, & I simply didn't have the mental capacity to take on a massive conglomerate like Greystar. They showed little care for my situation & still slapped me with late fees. It always felt like a constant uphill battle to get any fair treatment.
Then, move-out. Get ready to be nickel-&-dimed. You'll be hit with charges for painting, cleaning, & more. My advice? Don't bother cleaning I paid a cleaning lady, & still charged. Even worse, I'm now battling a collection notice, I paid for damage my guest supposedly caused to a door that was never actually replaced in the unit (it remained damaged for over a year, even after the subsequent tenant left!). When I asked for proof of the repair & final costs, they went ghost on me. Now, they're trying to stick me with the bill. It feels like they stole my money, trying to strong-arm me into paying for something that was never fixed or applied to my account. Luckily, I'm confident I'll win with collections, as most places can't provide proper initial contracts or proof.
In closing, transparency is a word often thrown around, but it's rarely what you get. There's so much hidden "crap" between you & the real story here. People will be people, but management's responsibility is to provide a safe, respectful, & functional environment. This place never truly grew into what it was meant to be. I desperately hope some of the genuinely good employees working for Greystar find better opportunities, and that this community eventually improves.
Living elsewhere, it's a huge relief to not be micromanaged by a leasing office with their own agendas, to breathe without constant judgment, and to not have to avoid people or cameras. Do your research. Arm yourself with knowledge. Weigh those pros and cons carefully. If I could give zero stars, I would. Management, please do not contact me or message back a waste of time.