John D.
Yelp
You Can Dish it Out, But You Pancake It
POV: You're staying in Solvang and have heard about these Danish pancakes that everyone is raving about. A cursory search of the Yelps brings up two very popular options: Ellen's Danish Pancake House (EPH) and Paula's Pancake House (PPH).
Both have solid reviews and a 4-star Yelp average--so which one should you choose?
Well, dear fellow Yelper, we've done the legwork for you so that you can make the right decision. Over the course of two days, we visited both places and ordered almost the exact same thing to do a head-to-head. Paula vs. Ellen--who's pancakes shall reign supreme?!
First, our orders: Carissa and I both ordered Danish pancakes w/ some protein on the side, while her son ordered his favorite Chicken Fried Steak from both establishments.
Backstory:
*Both are old established businesses with long ties to the community; PPH has been in business since '86, while EPH has been around since '47 and was once located in Solvang before moving to Buelton in '85. Neither are original owners fwiw.
Winner: EPH for longevity
Location:
*EPH is located in Buelton, which is a ±10min drive from Solvang, while PPH is located along the main drag in Solvang. Parking will never be an issue with EPH as they have a fairly large private lot, while PPH has limited parking in front, but lots of street and lot parking in the vicinity.
Winner: PPH
Ambiance and Décor:
*PPH's employees are dressed the part of being in a Danish village, and the interior décor definitely sells it, as well. EPH is, well, to put it kindly, looks like a typical diner you'd find in Anytown, USA.
Winner: PPH
Service:
*PPH employees are jovial, work hard, and friendly. EPH's waitress seemed to hate their lives and couldn't be bothered to crack a smile or be helpful in any way.
Winner: PPH
Value:
*After tax and 20% tip, the total to PPH was ±$70--while EPH came to OVER $100! Yes, you read that correctly. I almost couldn't believe my eyes when I saw it. There's must've been some diamonds encrusted in those pancakes I was unaware of...
Winner: PPH
Food:
*All-in-all, we felt like the food at PPH might've been just a skosh better, but nothing discernable. I felt like the pancakes were both about the same quality, but Carissa thought hers at PPH were a bit fluffier. As far as the Chicken Fried Steak, her son didn't really have an opinion on which was better, and said they were both "fine." *sigh* Kids...
Winner: Draw
Conclusion: With the food quality being the same, there's one clear winner here when it comes to value, service, and ambiance, and that's PPH. The only caveat with PPH is that they can get super busy during the breakfast rush, so my advice is to get there as close to opening as possible to avoid the crowds. Otherwise, be prepared to wait, but it's def worth it.