Bob A.
Yelp
Everyone used to love Elway's, a lot of folks are starting to complain about the prices, although that's pretty common in Vail.
We went there with our daughters March 2, 2025. I ordered a House Barrel Aged Manhattan, the waiter said it came with a large, square ice cube. I told him I wanted just regular, small ice cubes, but he seemed confused. I told him the big ones hit me in the nose, he laughed and I thought he understood. When the drink came (via 3rd party), the guy said "Here's the Manhattan with 3 small ice cubes." Not what I ordered, but I needed that drink badly.
The tuna tartare was good, my wife had the lamb chop appetizer which looked burned, but she said it was good. I don't eat meat, so I can't really speak to that.
My Caesar salad, which, to me is the crux of any meal, was a bunch of chopped Romaine, WAY too much shredded cheese and a very bland dressing. Was sorry I ordered it.
When I ordered the salmon, the waiter asked me which one, although there was only one on the menu that came with shrimp, lump crab meat and some kind of sauce. It was also available a la carte (without all that crap on it) for $12 less and that is the one I specified and pointed out to the waiter on the menu.
Of course I got the one with all the sauce and I couldn't eat it, so I just brought it home for the dog. Eating out in Vail ain't what it used to be and I guess I was just tired of sending stuff back.