Errol's Caribbean Delights

We come by here a lot for a bread pudding or coconut treat, and it’s always great. This week we tried one of their whole cakes, the Rocky Road, and it was a huge hit with the crowd! Light, moist and full of flavor. Highly recommend this spot if you have a sweet tooth!

We love the beef and callalloo patties but the whole place smells soo good! And the folks who run it /tend the counter are so kind. Highly recommend.

ordered the curry goat after some stumbling with the menu - there aren't labels describing what everything is, so i had to ask the person at the counter to help me with the names of all the dishes. ultimately happy with my order as i barely had any bones with my proteins and the curry was seasoned very well. my only ding would be that the rice and peas didn't taste much like anything, but that might have been because the curry was that much more flavorful. there is indoor seating!

Worst oxtail of my life. It was so hard and tasted funny like not like beef smh idk. It led me down this rabbit hole … aparently some people are serving something else and calling it oxtail. Idk man it tasted weird and I’m Caribbean it didn’t taste like beef and it was so tough mind you got it and it end of the night it was basically the last serving so why would it be tough and gamey tasting? I had to throw it out waste of 20$ …. Mind you I walked all the way down from cj’s out of my way to try this spot I should’ve just stuck with my gut and just got it from there because it’s actually tender and COW.. If I get food especially Caribbean food that’s about 1-2 meals for me , In this economy I don’t have time to be playing with my money. Not even my friend wanted to eat it and I would even try giving it to my dog.

The cakes need to be labeled and dated to determine and insure freshness. I had a piece of cake here that tasted absolutely disgusting and old. Very disappointing.

Went for the patties- shouldn't have. I knew upon sniffing the beef pattie that it was wrong - I grew up eating Jamaican patties and they NEVER smelled like these (had I gotten a whiff beforehand, I wouldn't have bothered). The crust used had not one iota of the fragrance of pattie crust. My friend urged me to taste, so I did - no flavor. In a beef pattie. I was shocked - total waste of time and money. My search for great Jamaican patties in Brooklyn continues - cuz they ain'tat Errol's.

Unfortunately despite the great taste of the Roti and oxtail I had, I guess because it had been sitting out for a long time after eating me and my some of my friends got food poisoning. So my advice do not order toward the end of their day or if the food looks kinda dry

Bought a fish soup that was half oil half water which tasted like water. I called to inform them that the soup was watery & no good & the woman who answered just said I’m sorry. After the soup sat for 3 hours after a nap. I went back to it & saw a third of it had oil sitting on the top. that was surprising because soup usually doesn’t have oil sitting so heavily. upon calling back to let them know this & wanting to bring it to show them, I was met with disrespect saying once I walk out with food there is no return on it. I’m said, “even if the food being served is no good?“ I was expecting a level of curiosity atleast from them to say bring it let me see or something. Instead she said … “once you walk out that it’s. & u called from this morning So either way u can’t bring it back. We don’t accept food back! So I was expected to go drink oily watery soup. Then once I said the Soup was oily she responded. It’s salmon and it’s tea not soup which clearly the menu said fish soup . I bought the soup around 11 am shouldn’t go bad by 3 pm. I would advice to not to buy food from here if your looking for quality food & service. If you’re into watery and oily soup, this is the place to go.