Neal M.
Yelp
Upscale dining brought to Delmar. Needs better execution. Make sure your food is clean. Also, PLEASE keep your receipts and check your final bills.
Environment: The restaurant oozes Mediterranean charm through the neutral colors accented by pink pastels, large windows, a small lounge area, an attractive bar, and an open kitchen. There is a subtle buzz throughout the restaurant which made us excited to see other patron's dishes come out and talk further about all the options on the menu. The staff started out very friendly, but we felt the service attentiveness decreased, until we found an issue with our meal (see below). They were also very knowledgeable about the menu and were able to answer all of our questions and tailor suggestions to our preferences. We were seated next to a large table that had all of their fresh cutlery, plates, and glasses, so we unfortunately saw high traffic of waiters near our table.
Food/Drink: Our meal started out spectacular. To drink we had the Basil Gimlet and Gibson Martini. Both drinks were strong and despite being simple, were made exceptionally well. The Basil Gimlet is a must try. As for our meal, we tried the cervelle de canut (onion dip), fire roasted beets, and the daily garden special (roasted eggplant dressed with chimichurri). They also bring a few slices of fresh bread and whipped butter to start. The bread was good, but the highlight was the salted, whipped butter which was light yet creamy.
The Onion Dip on its own was fantastic with a surprisingly rich onion flavor, but when paired with vegetables with high water content, all flavor from the onion dip was lost. The Fire Roasted Beets was probably our favorite of the night, which showcased a dance of earthy flavors from the beets, freshness from fennel and herbs, and acid from pickled watercress, tamed by a cool labne underneath. Would highly recommend this dish. Lastly, we tried the roasted eggplant daily special. This was absolutely bland and lacked salt. The chimichurri helped season the dish a bit, but still needed lots of help. The eggplant was also over-charred which overwhelmed the eggplant, clearing any eggplant flavor you could get from the dish.
As we started eating the eggplant, we noticed a HAIR IN THE DISH. The staff took the dish after examining it themselves. After this, we noticed our service get more attentive (seeming to be as a way to make up for their mistake and also maybe noticing that they weren't as attentive to our table). We saw a variety of people consistently checking our table. We were offered a replacement dish (truffle and mushroom lasagna), but were later told that they no longer had that dish, and were told to choose another item. We went with their vegetable lasanga, which was also unremarkable. The red sauce was made very well and balanced herbs and sweetness very well, but the sheets of pasta were uneven and there was barely any filling. It was a very small dish for $22.
After checking our bill a few days later, we also notice an UPCHARGE FROM WHAT WE PAID. We left a respectable 18% tip, but were upcharged an extra $4 on the tab after the meal. ***Bengelina/Ben Poremba group is known for this, as it has happened to us at Bar Moro and at Olio (now closed).*** I refrained from highlighting this in my reviews of those restaruants, but this is the third strike. It took time to get my money back from those other experiences, but I don't have the time to get my money back from my time at Esca.
Rating: 2/5 overall. Some of the dishes were made exceptionally well. Some needed better execution. Some need to be re-conceptualized. Also, for their opening weeks, finding a hair in our dish is in-excusable. Still, the food quality was good and we would give it 3/5. As for the declining service quality and issue with our credit card statement, we cannot give the experience more than a 1.
We chose this restaurant for a Birthday celebration, and left disappointed.
Please save your checks and look at your credit card statement after you visit any of the Bengelina/Ben Poremba group restaruants.