Heather P.
Yelp
Since I've lived in Lincoln Square, essentially the last 8 years, Essence of India has always been there. This is obviously saying a lot for an area that has experienced a ton of change and a revolving door of restaurants during that time. Being that we migrated from Lakeview, we already had our fave go to Indian joint so always intended to give Essence a try, but just never did. That is, until yesterday.
Went for lunch, one of three tables. Two employees working, atmosphere was dark and rather dreary. Music was nice and soothing. So far, so good. Ordered the non-vegetarian appetizer plate, read, all meat. It was delicious - there were four different types of meats (2 chicken, one lamb, and a large shrimp). Best part of the meal. Fantastic flavors and a variety of them. My absolute obsession was the Tandoori Shrimp.
For my entree, I ordered the Masala Coconut Shrimp. It did not include rice; which I'm not really used to, but not a deal breaker. The Naan I ordered alongside was great and garlicky. The chutneys that were on the table were tasty too. All good so far....until I tried my entree. Ick. I don't know what I was anticipating, but it wasn't this. Actually, I do know what I was anticipating, Masala with a hint of coconut milk. This was not the case. It was so sweet and even though at first I was disappointed that there wasn't rice, I wouldn't have used it anyway because I did not want any of the sauce, not even on the shrimp. The shrimp too were rubbery and small, zero seasoning or flavor on the shrimp on it's own, much different from my experience with the one Tandoori Shrimp from the appetizer.
Lesson learned, I ordered incorrectly. I also learned that I do not like Coconut Masala, not the color, not the flavor, not the smell. And, I will always order Tandoori Shrimp if I return; which is pretty unlikely.